Afternoon Nikita, ACK, we should of course use appropriate status ... I have only closed a few so far before I thought a discussion is probably in order, so no harm done.
Cheers Joe On Sun, Jan 8, 2017 at 10:29 AM, Nikita Popov <nikita....@gmail.com> wrote: > On Jan 8, 2017 7:47 AM, "Joe Watkins" <pthre...@pthreads.org> wrote: > > Morning internals, > > Some of you may have noticed that a few of us have put considerable effort > into cleanup of pull requests on github, these are now manageable and I'm > quite confident that we will be able to merge pull requests in a timely > manner, and stay on top of it. > > When it comes to bugsnet, there are feature requests and bugs that have > been open for more than 10 years, and nobody has talked about them in about > as long, they may concern defunct versions of PHP, or removed extensions or > SAPIs: These numbers in the thousands. > > It's very difficult (impossible) to see a good reason for these to be open, > they are not useful at all. > > With normal support for 5 ended, now is the perfect time to cleanup > bugsnet. If we can get the numbers down to something manageable, we have a > reasonable expectation to stay on top of them. > > I think anyone that has been waiting a number of years for a response to a > feature request deserves to know that it is not reasonably happening, and > that there are better ways of trying to get a feature in than opening > yet-another-feature-request on bugsnet. > > I think any bug report opened against 4 and not updated is useless. > > I think anything with a patch attached targeting 5 is useless, regardless > of age; they should be encouraged to open a pull request on github against > a supported branch. > > I'd like to hear what others think about cleaning up bugsnet, what criteria > we might use for a mass cleanup. > > After a mass cleanup, I/we will go in and start working through whatever is > left, but 5k mostly irrelevant bugs is too much to ask, it would take me > months and months to work through those, time that nobody has, or will ever > have. > > Cheers > Joe > > > As a general note: By convention the "Closed" state is only for bugs that > have been fixed or feature requests that have been implemented. If > something is not going to be fixed / implemented one of Won't Fix, Not a > Bug or Suspended should be used, as appropriate. > > Nikita >
