> So it is fine to have one setting doing the exact same thing? Sorry, I > disagree. We know we need that in other areas. Like other recent RFCs, > we have solved them bottom-up. This one is no different.
It's fine for an RFC to be focused on one thing. This is another subject. > So basically what you say is that this RFC, relying on things we > should clarify and define clearly so it will be consistent across the > engine and language, are not relevant to this RFC? I totally disagree > and hence my point that this RFC needs more (public) discussions and > things that are prerequisites for this RFC should be designed, > discussed and implemented before this RFC. I'm saying that this isn't a subject for this RFC, deciding if we're going to have multiple exception trees is simply not in scope. > I will certainly be the only one voting no at this stage, or maybe not > even voting because I simply feel like you discussed that already no > matter where and came to this RFC and say take it or leave it. I am > not a fan of this approach or we can rename "Request For Comments" to > "Request to Accept" as any kind of comments or feedback is simply not > taken into accounts. I'm sorry that you don't remember the discussion, but it did happen, the RFC has been in (more or less) it's current form for more than a year. The current form *is the result of discussion*. Please stop saying it hasn't been discussed, it has, a lot. Cheers Joe On Fri, Feb 20, 2015 at 3:48 PM, Crypto Compress < cryptocompr...@googlemail.com> wrote: > To be harsh: All comments in favour of throwing exceptions here, > substantiate theirs needs with dead, never reached and potentially buggy > code. > The *changed code flow in production* is the big pitfall of this RFC and > an absolute no-go. I like zero-cost assertions but throwing exceptions is > wrong. > > my 2 cents > > > ...exceptions are not used by default... >> > > Can't find this point in RFC. > > > -- > PHP Internals - PHP Runtime Development Mailing List > To unsubscribe, visit: http://www.php.net/unsub.php > >
