On 06/08/12 19:48, Stas Malyshev wrote:
Hi!
Personally, I'm used to what other languages like Python do, and I think
it makes more sense. Exceptions mean you can try/catch the things your
code needs to be prepared for (non-existence, maybe), but other things
No, they mean you need to *always* try/catch since you have to means to
check if the downstream function can throw and exception or maybe call
some other function that throws and exception. Exceptions propagate. In
Java, you have compiler-controlled throws (which doesn't work in 100% of
cases either - I regularly get exception messages from Eclipse, and this
one is written by people with great knowledge of Java) - in PHP, you
will have nothing. It's one thing when the code writes a warning and
returns null when something unexpected happens, another when it throws
and exception and you *have* to know which kind it will be and catch it
- or just catch everything and ignore it (because you have no idea what
it might be) and - check some success value then!
Why do you have to *always* try/catch? You're making the assumption you
need to check for and catch every error. You don't, unless you're
working with something like networking. Exceptions mean that an
exception, an error that infrequently pops up, but occasionally enough
that it matters, can be caught and dealt with. Other ones you don't have
to account for, because execution will just stop right there. You don't
need to bother checking the return value.
you haven't considered or are very unlikely, can just not be caught and
cause your code to halt execution. And it makes it harder to
accidentally avoid checking for errors and then wonder why $file is some
NULL or FALSE or other "error" value.
How it makes it harder? If you forget to check the result, you'll as
well forget to try/catch. It just makes the consequences worse - and
remember, this all happens in runtime!
With exceptions, your code stops running then and there. Without them,
with an unchecked return value, your code keeps going until it does
something stupid, which can be quite irritating to debug.
--
Andrew Faulds
http://ajf.me/
--
PHP Internals - PHP Runtime Development Mailing List
To unsubscribe, visit: http://www.php.net/unsub.php
