Hi!
Hey all,
I've created a draft version of the RFC for implementing __castTo()
and __assign():
https://wiki.php.net/rfc/object_cast_magic
I think having cast method may have merits, though use cases where
objects need to be converted to scalars that aren't string are very
limited, and cases where they need to do so transparently are almost
non-existent. I think what outlined in the RFC is a backdoor operator
overloading, through rather complex and unobvious magic. My opinion is
that outside of very limited number of cases (such as implementing
complex numbers or matrix algebra - and how frequently would one need do
that in PHP anyway?) operator overloading is way more trouble than it's
worth and makes code nearly unreadable as you never know what exactly
each operator does. For example, if($object) would have completely
different semantics than before, for some objects but not other, and
without any obvious clue to the user what it actually does - and all
that to save couple of keystrokes on if($object->valid())?
Still, if there's a valid use case found, cast magic method and
"unboxing" method may have merit. So far the cases outlined seem either
too artificial and narrow for language-level functionality, or plain
wrong (like SplFixedArray example - nothing in this proposal would
enable it to work with sort, for example). But I do not exclude other
cases can exist.
However, assignment overloading does not seem viable to me.
Also, I'm not sure how this is possible technically: $obj = {expression}
is supposed to replace $obj with the result of the expression, not call
methods on $obj. Doing otherwise would be huge change in the semantics,
a complete no go. Also, it's impossible if $obj is not set - meaning,
code $obj = 1 would mean totally different things depending on if $obj
is set or not - again, not a good idea. It also does not cover many
corner cases but I don't even want to go there since an idea to change
semantics of the assignment seems very wrong to me in principle, so no
need to go into the fine details.
--
Stanislav Malyshev, Software Architect
SugarCRM: http://www.sugarcrm.com/
(408)454-6900 ext. 227
--
PHP Internals - PHP Runtime Development Mailing List
To unsubscribe, visit: http://www.php.net/unsub.php
