Hi!
Here are the results of the votes. I've split them into "PHP Group" -
people that have write access to the PHP code, based on SVN karma
algorithm, and "Community" - all the rest. Here it goes:
Declare PHP/php as namespace reserved for PHP internals
--------------------------------------------------------
Votes: 57 total, 20 PHP Core, 37 community
For option PHP: PHP group support: 15 (75%), community: 28 (75%)
For option php: PHP group support: 14 (70%), community: 26 (70%)
This is clearly accepted. As it's docs only change, let's update the
docs accordingly.
3 people from PHP group voted against: auroraeosrose,cataphract,kalle.
It'd be interesting to know why, didn't hear anything on the list AFAIR.
Make primitive types (string, bool, int, etc.) reserved words
-------------------------------------------------------------
Removed for BC reasons, so no reason to count vote results.
Add E_STRICT to E_ALL
---------------------
Votes: 58 total, 23 PHP Core, 35 community
Every single voter supported it, nuff said.
Add option to disable POST data processing
------------------------------------------
Votes: 58 total, 23 PHP Core, 35 community
Again, accepted unanimously.
Support binary notation (0b1010101)
------------------------------------
Votes: 56 total, 21 PHP Core, 35 community
Unanimous again!
Remove magic quotes
--------------------
Votes: 54 total, 21 PHP Core, 33 community
For removal: PHP group support: 18 (85%), community: 32 (96%)
Again, 3 people voted against: derick,salathe,zeev. Any comments?
Array short syntax
-------------------
Votes: 61 total, 23 PHP Core, 38 community
First option (just brackets): PHP group support: 15 (65%), community: 28
(73%)
Second option (brackets and colons): PHP group support: 2 (8%),
community: 7 (18%)
Against both: PHP group support: 6 (26%), community: 3 (7%)
I think we can deem the first option passed, but not the second one.
Callable type check
-------------------
Votes: 51 total, 21 PHP Core, 30 community
For callable: PHP group support: 13 (61%), community: 21 (70%)
For callback: PHP group support: 8 (38%), community: 10 (33%)
Against both: PHP group support: 5 (23%), community: 1 (03%)
We have clear majority here for implementing it, but preference on the
name is less clear. Personally, I strongly urge that proposer would
consider not to add another mess in our documentation and call it what
it was always called in our docs. Otherwise, I guess documentation team
should go and fix all our docs to say "callable" now.
Change rebinding behavior of closures
-------------------------------------
Votes: 33 total, 10 PHP Core, 23 community
PHP group support: 10 (100%), community: 22 (95%)
Votes for this one are sparse, but unanimously in support. If we have no
BC issues there, it's in.
foreach adds list support
--------------------------
Votes: 32 total, 11 PHP Core, 21 community
For: PHP group support: 1 (9%), community: 8 (38%)
Rejected, at least for 5.4, sorry.
--
Stanislav Malyshev, Software Architect
SugarCRM: http://www.sugarcrm.com/
(408)454-6900 ext. 227
--
PHP Internals - PHP Runtime Development Mailing List
To unsubscribe, visit: http://www.php.net/unsub.php
