On Sat, Apr 2, 2011 at 12:41 PM, Stan Vass <sv_for...@fmethod.com> wrote:
> This is actually something I have been toying with a bit. Adding the >> ability to call methods on both strings and arrays. I still don't like >> the idea of making them real objects as the overhead and the amount of >> code that would need to be changed in the core and in every extension is >> daunting. Anybody out there have a patch along these lines? >> >> -Rasmus >> > > > Glad to see pseudo-object methods for scalars/arrays brought up again. > It'll improve workflow a lot. I want to ask/suggest two clarifications on > this: > > 1) You said 'strings and arrays', I hope that's 'scalars and arrays'. As > the current PHP semantics work, and with very minor exceptions, int/float > works as a numeric string when passed to a string function, and numeric > strings work when passed to a number function. > > I.e. those should work: > > $a = 1234; /* int */ echo $a->substr(1); // '234' > $a = '1.23456'; /* string */ $a->format(2); // '1.23' > > This means the extension methods for primitives should be split in two > groups: > > arrays (lists and maps) - one API set > scalars (bool, int, float, strings) - one API set > > 2) Because the language currently has no scalar hinting (I know it's > coming), IDE autocompletion of the extension methods may not work very well > (unless the IDE assumes everything is a scalar unless hinted otherwise). > > Both hinting, incl. for method/function return types, and extension methods > should be introduced together as they make each other more useful, than > independently. > > Let me know what you think. > > Stan Vass > > -- > PHP Internals - PHP Runtime Development Mailing List > To unsubscribe, visit: http://www.php.net/unsub.php > > What about a marker interface hierarchy like this? interface Mixed { } interface Numeric { } interface Callable extends Mixed { } interface Resource extends Mixed { } interface Scalar extends Mixed { } interface Array extends Mixed { } // unexpected T_ARRAY interface Object extends Mixed { } interface Boolean extends Scalar { } interface String extends Scalar, Numeric { } interface Number extends Scalar, Numeric { } interface Float extends Number { } interface Integer extends Number { } ( http://graph.gafol.net/etSevVPSJ ) This way the core will know which methods are allowed to call on each $var Advantages: * cannnot create instances * cannot extends these interfaces (private to core) * very very fine type hint * core implementation is not exposed Martin Scotta
