On 5/15/2013 7:49 AM, Ralph Droms wrote:
>The DISCUSS isn't there to make documents "better" - that's for COMMENTs. A DISCUSS there to catch a set of problems and to*block* the document's progress until that problem is resolved.
I'll agree with you *if* you consider an unclear description of a feature of a protocol, severe enough that reader of the specification are not able to build interoperable implementations, as a problem for which a DISCUSS can be posted. In my opinion, there are many ways in which document can be unclear beyond the "motivation for a particular feature of a protocol is not clear enough." - Ralph
Absolutely. Note that issues interfering with interoperability or correctness are among the explicit DISCUSS criteria.
Joe
