> If you could design applications that can work with NAT > enroute, without needing an ALG; that would be great. > But, if the applications do require an ALG enroute > (as in the case of voice-over-IP which uses out-of-band > call-control segnalling), then the application designers should also > consider what it takes to build an ALG enroute. The problem of encrypted signaling remains, however. Should you choose to deal with this problem by terminating signaling on the ALG you have to consider the performance implications, as well, which have very real consequences when dealing with timing requirements imposed by interworking with the PSTN, where applicable. Not to mention, of course, key management soup. ALGs are a good solution for many NAT-related problems, but not for all of them. Melinda -- Melinda Shore Member of the Scientific Staff Nokia IP Telephony 127 West State Street Ithaca, NY 14850 +1 607 273 0724 (office) +1 607 275 3610 (fax) +1 607 227 4096 (mobile) [EMAIL PROTECTED]
- Re: IP network address assignments/allocation... John Day
- Re: IP network address assignments/alloca... Mark Atwood
- Re: IP network address assignments/al... John Day
- Application name space and ASN.1 ... Harald Tveit Alvestrand
- Re: Application name space a... John Day
- Re: IP network address assignments/alloca... Thomas Narten
- Re: IP network address assignments/allocations inf... Pyda Srisuresh
- Re: IP network address assignments/allocations inf... Pyda Srisuresh
- Re: IP network address assignments/allocations inf... Bob Braden
- RE: IP network address assignments/allocations inf... Melinda . Shore
- RE: IP network address assignments/allocations inf... Ian King
- RE: IP network address assignments/allocations inf... Tony Hain (Exchange)
- RE: IP network address assignments/allocation... Paul Ferguson
- Re: IP network address assignments/alloca... Jon Crowcroft
- Re: IP network address assignments/al... Perry E. Metzger
- Re: IP network address assignment... Yakov Rekhter
- Re: IP network address assignment... Brian E Carpenter
- Re: IP network address assig... Perry E. Metzger
- Re: IP network address a... Randy Bush
- Re: IP network address a... Perry E. Metzger