Tobias Herkula wrote in <fr3p281mb29748a89a7c08680010837d1ea...@fr3p281mb2974.deup281.prod.OUTLO\ OK.COM>: |I'm part of that SMTP audience and I'm looking forward to reducing \ |the number of RCPT-TOs in a transaction to one. I also think of the \
Reasons. Give me just one reason! I have mailing-lists myself, and lots of gmail addresses. All of these are bundled. (In several distinct, mind you, that many there are.) |joy of having a cryptographic signature that covers MAIL-FROM and RCPT-TO \ |in addition to the already covered headers and the body of an email. \ Ha! Me too. |Bringing up privacy risks for a protocol like SMTP is a lame excuse \ |as, while SMTP is stable, there is a lack of any privacy related functio\ |nality in the base protocol that were only solved by additions over time. Surely not. It is the IETF which caused the problems, why you point this reasoning against me? I was talking about that for years. |The re-chartering of the DKIM WG comes from a lot of frustrations Mailbox \ |Providers have in the current ecosystem that we (at least I) want to \ |solve with the involvement of the community and not by side stepping \ |it and coming around with a finished and polished solution. So you \ |can see this as another addition to the SMTP world that will hopefully \ |solve the problems that are still around. Problems that were perhaps \ |lightheartedly described in the charter but are real problems that \ |at least for me as a Mailbox Provider I have to fight every single day. | |The only argument I find in your comments are, “I don’t want this to \ |change and therefore I am against this change.“ I don’t think that \ |this is a proper way to go forward in an ever changing environment. This is malicously bending the reality of the last years. It is lacking any truthfulness. It luckily stands on hollow ground. ..eh,..one more. Who is side stepping and coming around with a finished and polished solution? It is even low standard. --steffen | |Der Kragenbaer, The moon bear, |der holt sich munter he cheerfully and one by one |einen nach dem anderen runter wa.ks himself off |(By Robert Gernhardt) _______________________________________________ Ietf-dkim mailing list -- ietf-dkim@ietf.org To unsubscribe send an email to ietf-dkim-le...@ietf.org
