Hi Peter,

EATTR settings are the same (blank) for both DataClasses. When allocating with 
either DataClass, IEHLIST shows EATTR=NS and ISPF shows no 'Extended 
Attributes' line in the Data Set Information panel.

When allocating with explicit EATTR=NO on the DD-Statement (using the same 
DataClasses), IEHLIST shows EATTR=NO and the ISPF Data Set Information panel 
shows 'Extended Attributes   NO', but the behaviour is still the same for each 
DataClass (one is OK, one is not OK).

I've attached the LISTVTOC output for 4 cases as follows:
T601386.ISIS71.SYSPRIN1: Allocated with DataClass SNN (1 Record)
T601386.ISIS71.SYSPRIN2: Allocated with DataClass SNNSV (all Records)
T601386.ISIS71.SYSPRIN3: Allocated with DataClass SNN, EATTR=NO in JCL (1 
Record)
T601386.ISIS71.SYSPRIN4: Allocated with DataClass=SNNSV, EATTR=NO in JCL (all 
Records)

The only difference I can see between the OK and the not-OK datasets is the 
last block pointer, which shows track 4 for the OK cases and track 0 for the 
not-OK cases.

Any other ideas?

Thanks, Beat



On Sat, 30 Aug 2014 11:03:58 +0200, Peter Hunkeler <[email protected]> wrote:

>Hi Beat,
>I've had numerous problems with weird behavior of the software when
>datasets were allocated on EAV volumes with the data set extended
>attribute (EATTR) set to "Opt" and the software was not prepared for
>this. EATTR=OPT allows the data set to reside in the extended
>addressability are ov EAV volumes. Needs new DSCB formats, has
>different record addressing (more bits for the cylinder), and
>probably more.
>
>Fact is that IBM as well as vendor software is not always well
>prepared to deal with this. Depending on how "deep" the software
>dives into the I/O business, it may or may not work. If it doesn't,
>the resulting false behaviour does not point you directly to
>EATTR=OPT.
>
>EATTR is another parameter set by the DataClass. Data sets with
>EATTR=OPT do show this in ISPF's data set information panel.
>
>Can you verify the EATTR settings in both DataClasses you mentioned?
>
>
>--
>Peter Hunkeler
>
>
>Beat Gossweiler wrote on August 23:
>
> > I'm investigating a mysterious problem with a vendor product (batch
> > program called from JCL) writing to SYSPRINT, which shows the
> > following symptoms:
> >
> > 1) When allocating SYSPRINT to SYSOUT, I can see all expected records
> > (messages) in the spool file (-> OK)
> >
> > 2) When allocating to an SMS managed PS dataset (DISP=(NEW,CATLG))
> > with our default DataClass, the dataset only contains the last record
> > of what was written to spool in case 1 (-> Not OK)
> >
> > 3) When allocating to a temporary dataset (which is not SMS managed),
> > the temporary dataset contains all the records which were written to
> > spool in case 1 (-> OK)
> >
> > 4) When allocating to a SMS managed PS dataset (DISP=(NEW,CATLG))
> > with a different DataClass, the cataloged dataset contains all the
> > records which were written to spool in case 1 (-> OK)
> >
> > - the vendor is not able to reproduce my symptoms on his z/OS system
> > - the vendor product runs in an LE environment
> > - I don't know what access method is used for SYSPRINT by the product
> > - I suspect the product uses more than one DCB from different threads
> > to write concurrently to SYSPRINT (i.e. the last message comes from a
> > separate unit of work). This might be wrong, but why would it work
> > (consistently) with certain types of DASD datasets?
> >
> > - the major difference I can see between the two DataClasses in use
> > is that the working DataClass does not specify space constraint
> > relief, but I have to further investigate for differences.
> >
> >
> > Can anybody provide me with a clue on where to look further for the
> > root cause of this problem? Getting more detailed information about
> > the techniques used in the product from the vendor is not an option
> > at this point of time.
> >
> > Thanks for any hints
> > Beat
>
>----------------------------------------------------------------------
>For IBM-MAIN subscribe / signoff / archive access instructions,
>send email to [email protected] with the message: INFO IBM-MAIN


----------------------------------------------------------------------
For IBM-MAIN subscribe / signoff / archive access instructions,
send email to [email protected] with the message: INFO IBM-MAIN
                              SYSTEMS SUPPORT UTILITIES---IEHLIST               
                PAGE    1                
DATE: 2014.244  TIME: 13.39.44                                                  
                                         
                CONTENTS OF VTOC ON VOL DWA011  <THIS IS AN SMS MANAGED VOLUME> 
                                         
---------------DATA SET NAME----------------  SER NO  SEQNO  DATE.CRE  DATE.EXP 
 DATE.REF  EXT DSORG RECFM OPTCD BLKSIZE 
T601386.ISIS71.SYSPRIN1                       DWA011      1  2014.244    00.000 
 2014.244    1  PS   VB     00    22978  
SMS.IND   LRECL  KEYLEN  INITIAL ALLOC  2ND ALLOC    EXTEND       LAST 
BLK(T-R-L)  DIR.REM  F2 OR F3(C-H-R)  DSCB(C-H-R) 
S         22974            TRKS              15                         4   2 
31076                            1   3   2 
EATTR                                                                           
                                         
NS                                                                              
                                         
            EXTENTS  NO  LOW(C-H)   HIGH(C-H)                                   
                                         
                       0  1636  0     1636  4                                   
                                         
                                ----ON THE ABOVE DATA SET,THERE ARE          0 
EMPTY TRACK(S).                           
                                                                                
                                         
                              SYSTEMS SUPPORT UTILITIES---IEHLIST               
                PAGE    1                
DATE: 2014.244  TIME: 13.40.10                                                  
                                         
                CONTENTS OF VTOC ON VOL DWA005  <THIS IS AN SMS MANAGED VOLUME> 
                                         
---------------DATA SET NAME----------------  SER NO  SEQNO  DATE.CRE  DATE.EXP 
 DATE.REF  EXT DSORG RECFM OPTCD BLKSIZE 
T601386.ISIS71.SYSPRIN2                       DWA005      1  2014.244    00.000 
 2014.244    1  PS   VB     00    22978  
SMS.IND   LRECL  KEYLEN  INITIAL ALLOC  2ND ALLOC    EXTEND       LAST 
BLK(T-R-L)  DIR.REM  F2 OR F3(C-H-R)  DSCB(C-H-R) 
S         22974            TRKS              15                         0   1 
58004                            0   7   7 
EATTR                                                                           
                                         
NS                                                                              
                                         
            EXTENTS  NO  LOW(C-H)   HIGH(C-H)                                   
                                         
                       0   561  0      561  0                                   
                                         
                                ----ON THE ABOVE DATA SET,THERE ARE          0 
EMPTY TRACK(S).                           
                                                                                
                                         
                              SYSTEMS SUPPORT UTILITIES---IEHLIST               
                PAGE    1                
DATE: 2014.244  TIME: 13.40.24                                                  
                                         
                CONTENTS OF VTOC ON VOL DWA003  <THIS IS AN SMS MANAGED VOLUME> 
                                         
---------------DATA SET NAME----------------  SER NO  SEQNO  DATE.CRE  DATE.EXP 
 DATE.REF  EXT DSORG RECFM OPTCD BLKSIZE 
T601386.ISIS71.SYSPRIN3                       DWA003      1  2014.244    00.000 
 2014.244    1  PS   VB     00    22978  
SMS.IND   LRECL  KEYLEN  INITIAL ALLOC  2ND ALLOC    EXTEND       LAST 
BLK(T-R-L)  DIR.REM  F2 OR F3(C-H-R)  DSCB(C-H-R) 
S     A   22974            TRKS              15                         4   2 
31076                            0   3  45 
EATTR                                                                           
                                         
NO                                                                              
                                         
            EXTENTS  NO  LOW(C-H)   HIGH(C-H)                                   
                                         
                       0   866  0      866  4                                   
                                         
                                ----ON THE ABOVE DATA SET,THERE ARE          0 
EMPTY TRACK(S).                           
                                                                                
                                         
                              SYSTEMS SUPPORT UTILITIES---IEHLIST               
                PAGE    1                
DATE: 2014.244  TIME: 13.40.33                                                  
                                         
                CONTENTS OF VTOC ON VOL DWA003  <THIS IS AN SMS MANAGED VOLUME> 
                                         
---------------DATA SET NAME----------------  SER NO  SEQNO  DATE.CRE  DATE.EXP 
 DATE.REF  EXT DSORG RECFM OPTCD BLKSIZE 
T601386.ISIS71.SYSPRIN4                       DWA003      1  2014.244    00.000 
 2014.244    1  PS   VB     00    22978  
SMS.IND   LRECL  KEYLEN  INITIAL ALLOC  2ND ALLOC    EXTEND       LAST 
BLK(T-R-L)  DIR.REM  F2 OR F3(C-H-R)  DSCB(C-H-R) 
S     A   22974            TRKS              15                         0   1 
58004                            0  13  33 
EATTR                                                                           
                                         
NO                                                                              
                                         
            EXTENTS  NO  LOW(C-H)   HIGH(C-H)                                   
                                         
                       0  1012 14     1012 14                                   
                                         
                                ----ON THE ABOVE DATA SET,THERE ARE          0 
EMPTY TRACK(S).                           
                                                                                
                                         



----------------------------------------------------------------------
For IBM-MAIN subscribe / signoff / archive access instructions,
send email to [email protected] with the message: INFO IBM-MAIN

Reply via email to