Correct, they make it so that you can verify that the user is trusted by that 
domain to be that person, i.e. they had the proper password and authenticated 
with them to send the email in the first place.  The email address they used 
has to be authenticated with my software on the automation side, and if their 
address matches the one we allow, and IF they have passed the SPF, DKIM, and 
DMARC verification (meaning that they properly authenticated with the server on 
their end), then they are trusted to issue commands, but even then, the 
commands they are trusted to use are still limited by the internal security 
rules.  

SO, if and only if they pass all of that security checking, then they can issue 
some subset of commands or provide the okay for something to proceed.  

Brian

On Mon, 24 Aug 2026 18:16:10 +1000, Andrew Rowley 
<[email protected]> wrote:

>My understanding is that SPF, DKIM and DMARC are more about who is
>authorised to send email at the domain level rather than authenticating
>an address. That might include external organizations, e.g. marketing
>and might be wider than you really want for security. Also email is
>usually delivered quickly but can be delayed, so there is some danger
>that a message is received hours or even days later.
>
>Responding to an event sounds a more likely prospect than unsolicited
>automation actions. Then you could e.g. have a random key in the email
>to include in a reply to authenticate it. Make it time limited and
>single use. Responding via SMS might be more useful - maybe you already
>offer that?
>
>On 24/08/2026 4:14 pm, Brian Westerman wrote:
>> I keep a table information from the last 1,000 emails that were processed 
>> and do several checks on them to make sure things are secure, but the most 
>> important part of security is the email address that has to be pre-approved 
>> on the mainframe side that they use and that it is the one attached to the 
>> site that we allow requests from and that they also passed the SPF, DKIM and 
>> DMARC tests which make it unlikely that they were bogus.
>>
>> Brian
>
>--
>Andrew Rowley
>Black Hill Software
>
>
>----------------------------------------------------------------------
>For IBM-MAIN subscribe / signoff / archive access instructions,
>send email to [email protected] with the message: INFO IBM-MAIN

----------------------------------------------------------------------
For IBM-MAIN subscribe / signoff / archive access instructions,
send email to [email protected] with the message: INFO IBM-MAIN

Reply via email to