Al few comments:

1 - In 1973 at the university, we had the chance to learn programming using the SIMULA 67 implementation fo 360/370.

    To me one of the influences of 80 column cards was that the compiler had 
(i.e. HAS) an option

    INDENT=n

    which indented the listing between BEGIN END pairs.

    As a consequence no leading spaces on cards were wasted.

2 - If one obeys a strict indentation rule in C ( indent between  { } )
     then the { } become redundant
     (Ignoring the desire for indentation in complex expresssins)
     Thus, python.

3 - Ladders in IF THEN ELSE IF THEN ELSE IF ..
     are IMHO not nice.

4 -  Most languages use patterns like (add DO/BEGIN/{ }/END around f indented 
lines

     try something;
     IF successful
     THEN
         blabla
     ELSE
         try something else
         IF successful
        THEN

     I'd prefer

     IF
        try something
        successful
     THEN
        blabla
     ELSEIF
        try something else
        successful
     THEN

which in a loop gives

    WHILE
         try next
         more to do
    LOOP
        ....
    ENDWHILE

instead of in some puristic (non exit if or leave )

      try next (actually first)
      WHILE
            more to do
      LOOP
           ....
          try next
      ENDWHILE

At GMD where I worked since I was 20, worked with and on a structured programming assembler macro set. (CBTTAPE 1005)
Hm, should update this after 40 years.

5 - side effects:

     Koster's CDL2  used 4 types of routines
     functions and tests (no side effects)
     actions  (has side effects)
     predicates (like a test bif false, if result is true, has side effect)

     The 'try something' above should be implemented as predicates
     parsers consume input  like is('+) checks whether the next char is a + and 
consumes it if so.

         is('+) , addnextoperand() ;
         is('-') , subtractnextoperant() .

6 - The inventors of SIMULA 67 seem to have said that (computer) languages are not meant to last more than 3  years (as is),
     As a corollary, one should at least try and start learning  a new one each 
three years :-)

7 -  Indiana PI bill
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indiana_Pi_Bill      just postponed!!

Best
*
*






----------------------------------------------------------------------
For IBM-MAIN subscribe / signoff / archive access instructions,
send email to [email protected] with the message: INFO IBM-MAIN

Reply via email to