I am not sure I understand everything you said. how about you take 20 mins tomorrow during our Hibernate NoORM team meeting on IRC? Be careful, 20 mins run fast in practice :)
On 12 May 2014, at 17:38, Sanne Grinovero <sa...@hibernate.org> wrote: > Now that finally Infinispan moved to build (and require) Java7, I'm > preparing to upgrade the Lucene Directory to Apache Lucene 4.8. > > Sometimes it's trivial, some others we're out of luck and this is one > of such situations: the new Lucene code expects some new methods to > create and validate a CRC32 checksum signature of the Directory > segments. > Not too annoying - I can handle the coding - but it highlights an old > problem which is coming back. > > Currently Infinispan is still using Hibernate Search 4.5, and provides > a Lucene Directory for both Lucene versions 3 and 4. > The current build provides the LuceneV4 support as an extension of the > V3 source module; this is a hack we introduced a year ago to make sure > we'd eventually be able to upgrade to Lucene4 and I was hoping now to > finally remove this fishy workaround as I initially expected it to be > a temporary measure. > > But in practice such an upgrade of today would have been impossible: > Infinispan also depends on Hibernate Search. Having two different > modules in Infinispan is what enables us today to start an update to a > new version of Lucene. > > I'm wondering if we should move the Lucene Directory code into > Hibernate Search; this also has licensing implications as that's using > ASL2 currently. And that's probably only moving the problem one step > down, as Infinispan Query still depends on Hibernate Search (engine) > and the Lucene Directory would still depend on Infinispan Core. > > I'm not having a solution in mind; obviously we wouldn't have such a > problem if each of our projects *always* guaranteed a clean migration > path via default methods and deprecated methods, but this is a rule > which is occasionally broken: when it happens, the only thing I can > think of is that one of the two projects needs to release a tag which > has some broken components. For example, Infinispan to release > occasionally without the Query engine. > > Sanne > _______________________________________________ > hibernate-dev mailing list > hibernate-dev@lists.jboss.org > https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/hibernate-dev _______________________________________________ hibernate-dev mailing list hibernate-dev@lists.jboss.org https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/hibernate-dev
