I see where you're coming from. There are two options: - don't care that much - rename default to default_for_index or index_default (or some long and annoying name like that) and deprecate default
Do you really think filter is in as much need as index for a default? Any other category that would be in need for that? On 11 oct. 2011, at 17:39, Sanne Grinovero wrote: >> >> I am against it. All the doc is consistent, I don't want two options to do >> one thing if they are strictly equivalent. > > Sure, I'm not suggesting to support it: as I've written in the > description of HSEARCH-942 such a property should log a warning: we > could warn only, but we could also warn and still apply the property. > I'm happy to warn only if you prefer. > >>> on b) : I really think this ".default" business got out of hand; it >>> made sense in initial days as there wasn't much to configure, but >>> nowaday? Is it still self-speaking that "default" relates to the >>> IndexManager / indexes ? >> >> Can you be specific? default is a great way to apply the same behavior for >> all of your indexes. Unless I've lost a train, using the same type of >> backend with the same settings is likely to be the most probable choice for >> a lot of deployments. > > There are properties which are not related to a specific IndexManager: > > _hibernate.search.lucene_version_ > _hibernate.search.filter.cache_docidresults.size_ > > and some which are: > > _hibernate.search.default.directory_provider_ > _hibernate.search.default.indexwriter.merge_factor_ > > I definitely like the default mechanics, what I'm pointing out is that > it's not clear that "default" is referring to the "default index", > which is an abstract contept to make it harder. > > If this was a method to specify a default value for any property, I > would expect it to work too for > > _hibernate.search.default.filter.cache_docidresults.size_ > > (which doesn't work as it's a different category). _______________________________________________ hibernate-dev mailing list hibernate-dev@lists.jboss.org https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/hibernate-dev
