Hello,

in fact I was facing similar problems before, however the problem is more of a Lucene problem than a Hibernate Search one.
Sure, but it doesn't mean HS can't solve it :)

There are some threads regarding "error tolerant" query parsers on the Lucene mailing list. There are several approaches to the problem. You could catch the ParseException and inspect the error message. According to some post it should be possible to extract the cause of the error from the excpetion and maybe modify the query. A simpler approach might be to use QueryParser.escape() in case a ParseException occurs and
just escape the whole query string.
You're right, the parsing error is quite well described (not in string form, but "programatically") in the exception. So implementing what I wrote about earlier would be even easier that I suspected. I'll let you know when I'm done with it :).

I think just using QueryParser.parse() out of the box is most of the times not sufficient and you always have to write some custom code around query generation and handling. The question is whether any custom parser is generic enough to be used in a wide range of applications. I like the idea of a google
like query parser though. I wonder how Nutch is works in this area.
Well, as I wrote, I think that supporting Google-like queries would be a good "generic" parser. If the user builds a simple searchable website (with Seam) and wants a "search" box to search through his content such a parser would be what he expects to have in HS (unless his needs are that simple to just send a "site:www.mysite.com query" query to google :) ).

--
Adam
_______________________________________________
hibernate-dev mailing list
hibernate-dev@lists.jboss.org
https://lists.jboss.org/mailman/listinfo/hibernate-dev

Reply via email to