Hi Kevin, I am not sure about the NAT part. But I am running 0.20 on a public IP address. My node ID is CCXHBE49GRQVFAVFQ3BXVXPHHD63NG6ZNY31R0F59KVDZQA42PTG
Can you try adding `http://clehaxze.tw:9876/` to your hostlist provider? I've opened mine for others to use too. Martin > gnunet-core Mon Dec 18 10:12:58 2023: connection established 5GYZ (timeout in 298 s) Mon Dec 18 10:12:58 2023: connection established 008Q (timeout in 299 s) Mon Dec 18 10:12:58 2023: connection established FGXY (timeout in 299 s) Mon Dec 18 10:12:58 2023: connection established 1YGN (timeout in 262 s) Mon Dec 18 10:12:58 2023: connection established 1T8F (timeout in 296 s) Mon Dec 18 10:12:58 2023: connection established DESN (timeout in 299 s) Mon Dec 18 10:12:58 2023: connection established 51V4 (timeout in 290 s) Mon Dec 18 10:12:58 2023: connection established DRD4 (timeout in 297 s) Mon Dec 18 10:12:58 2023: connection established SMS8 (timeout in 200 s) gnunet-cadet -P 008Q3SKSXDAQDBMKZSJ4VHPVV2ZNG9PF783RA4132SD96PRJZ1Z0 tunnel: N, paths: 1 RJCSG4Z1AMS9PFTCQBX95CWRTR3BRD0FCRXQ90CCA1Y31KEQH47G tunnel: N, paths: 1 SMS8ADJPF83165FG78EEZ0EJCNCDDBQPQR5S5KN56NKG2W3BCDCG tunnel: N, paths: 1 1T8FY3QRXC4XJWWG8X7T2NYNVAM00CNVDTE4AQQEVB6PQ3ED8MC0 tunnel: N, paths: 1 1YGNJFY3VM6VQYY9M8K80ZZ9233TCBSZDQG93NSJM7J0T47D9VY0 tunnel: Y, paths: 2 JJ1N7W3C36XQT272JTXTD331H8196V09C37BM7Y433WXZ8ZA82DG tunnel: Y, paths: 0 AKN0F88HH4BQY1TB5Z2V6PRF3KWKFCCRZBJYVH0BD7P4S1D0NJF0 tunnel: N, paths: 2 V8XXK9GAN5ZJFRFQP8MQX3D83BZTSBQVHKWWD0JPE63Z821906EG tunnel: N, paths: 0 KHHRWZ0MYZVPWR5NQGFV5T15GE0M01TP4WJ8ZKRENYA8TZE038A0 tunnel: Y, paths: 0 KW7VNM3R256MCFBA5BJ644NXQC9NX58VRFBSQB15M76B4YTQR10G tunnel: Y, paths: 0 CCXHBE49GRQVFAVFQ3BXVXPHHD63NG6ZNY31R0F59KVDZQA42PTG tunnel: N, paths: 0 WH8J95E3GVC9C54G0AV7EYY744TZ7NV4TXDGFWN5XCM770CN0HT0 tunnel: N, paths: 2 MHBHB5BH2V877T1W8CE9BNXTV3P4Q43H12J3Q7DQKP2S9QFJ301G tunnel: Y, paths: 0 CR0V1C1P529RDWKMSP64MGWPT5E8VZARYZH2J5B6W2YED66WWKK0 tunnel: N, paths: 0 51V4ZGBXA7E5WQF9WHW5KWNYYP7TRA10FWF1SPEVZRTC5G2K75N0 tunnel: N, paths: 1 DESNPFW7GF0NT3XZ9GJ5JPK18JF6DFZ9PD01QS31X8T93AN8X12G tunnel: N, paths: 1 5GYZVBTD5K0WCSVQGRHG18ZDBC3TT6905M34R9WKWQZHD906PDBG tunnel: N, paths: 4 NNQMC4284WYAKYKSK8WE4T4NJBC4SARXC1MR67DPRVAVNJJRYP6G tunnel: Y, paths: 0 DRD47JG4E9X1B67TXHV9M6V03RYD415FGCSA63X11F23NRRXDQFG tunnel: N, paths: 1 DSTJBRRKZ8TBW3FGK6B0M5QXWT9WYNZ45H5MCV4HY7ST64Q8T9F0 tunnel: N, paths: 0 Y924NSHMMZ1N1SQCE5TXF93ED6S6JY311K0QT86G9WJC68F6XVZ0 tunnel: N, paths: 0 7EQ9XKYTQSDZZ735A2XQ5YG7RBN4VNDBJ1EGX7QXVQDF2SGGENXG tunnel: N, paths: 1 FGXY5RP0YJBS4XSMG0ERWBE4YQPWQ712VSJ6PJ6FSVDQDDXE5NC0 tunnel: N, paths: 1 QRKT0506TTR7TG940NNYFPX5GCT83YZQAAYA81TE48XYG5WD34AG tunnel: Y, paths: 0 On Monday, December 18th, 2023 at 7:20 AM, Kevin Steen <gnu...@kevinsteen.net> wrote: > Greetings > > Firstly, congratulations on getting the RFC published! > > I've managed to get GNUnet v0.20 running by installing from the Debian > Testing repository, but it doesn't seem to be connecting to any peers. > Are there any compatible peers running, or is everyone running an > incompatible version straight from source? > > The hostlist URL used by this version ("http://v15.gnunet.org/hostlist";) > refuses connections, but I found "https://gnunet.io/hostlist"; which > seems to return some data after I added it to the config. > > `gnunet-cadet -P` gives me: > Y924NSHMMZ1N1SQCE5TXF93ED6S6JY311K0QT86G9WJC68F6XVZ0 tunnel: N, paths: 0 > V8XXK9GAN5ZJFRFQP8MQX3D83BZTSBQVHKWWD0JPE63Z821906EG tunnel: N, paths: 0 > DSTJBRRKZ8TBW3FGK6B0M5QXWT9WYNZ45H5MCV4HY7ST64Q8T9F0 tunnel: N, paths: 0 > QTJ1MHPKXY1HTRJGBP1WDETBGFZ8QK27RDTNBMZ5JBV6TPY2YYWG tunnel: N, paths: 0 > > and `gnunet-core` returns nothing. > > If someone could post the output of `gnunet-peerinfo -g` I would > appreciate it. > > I'm behind a CG-NAT setup, so outgoing connections only - will GNUnet be > able to operate at all? > > Thanks in advance > -Kevin > > -- > Following the easy path, strewn with treats, is how animals end up in cages.
