On 16/02/2025 12:19, Maxime Devos wrote:

I'm going to look into what's the case for 'tan'. For 'tan', tan(pi/4)=tan(45°) is rational as well - I'm going to look into whether the 'S' of 'tan' is only the integer multiples pi/4, or whether there are more.

It's only those:

For which θ is θ/π and tan(θ) rational?
Assume t=tan(θ)∈ℚ. Note that sin (2θ)=(2t)/(1+t^2)∈ℚ. Since sin(2θ) is rational and 2θ/π is rational, then 2θ is an integer multiple of π/2. So, θ is an integer multiple of π/4.

This is untrue, there are a few other angles (that are rational multiples of pi) for which sin is rational. The same approach should work, though.


Reply via email to