El vie, 20-02-2009 a las 20:02 -0500, Isaac Dupree escribió: > Jan Alsenz wrote: > > Yes, that was my point. You need a trusted first step. > > But the only thing besides a TPM, that can be used for this is the BIOS, > > which can be flashed. > > And even, if we assume, that we can construct a BIOS that only boots if the > > MBR hash matches and can not be flashed prior to this point, there are > > still two points missing: > > - After the system has started, the BIOS could be flashed. This is a very > > possible scenario in a multi user environment. > > - They could take out the disk and put it in another machine, tamper with > > the boot code and switch it on. And all your protection is gone. > > Ok, you could try to put a needed key in the BIOS too, but then we're > > back to problem one - and the BIOS can not check if a request for the key > > is valid. I'm not even sure, if something in the BIOS can be read > > protected. > > BIOS could be in ROM, un-flashable, including hash/keys and all! Refuse to > boot if the hash doesn't match! Admittedly this poses some limitations on > whether the system can be upgraded, depending how sophisticated you want to > be.
This paranoid security talk is growing some big pink elephants which are being conveniently ignored: you people are trying to protect a HD within a computer that could be stolen, but you trust that the BIOS chip (in ROM and whatever you want), which performs the systems initialization (including RAM and the TPM) cannot be tampered with or even replaced. When someone pointed the key-in-RAM problem the answer was "I'll just glue it with epoxy resin"! For crying out loud! Without taking into account that most epoxy resins take weeks to solidify under 100 ºC, if the computer is physically stolen it could be subjected to EM-field analysis. What will be the next madness? Will you wrap every RAM module in tinfoil, a-la Faraday cage? Will you build a plasma shield around them? This is going way out of proportion: with non-interactive key initialization, if the computer is stolen, you are screwed period, because you have a Mallory-on-steroids-holding-Alice-ransom instead of a tame Eve. It does not take a rocket scientist (what I'm studying) nor a cryptographer (one of my hobbies) to notice! -- -- Lazy, Oblivious, Rational Disaster -- Habbit
signature.asc
Description: Esta parte del mensaje está firmada digitalmente
_______________________________________________ Grub-devel mailing list Grub-devel@gnu.org http://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/grub-devel
