Also to follow up on one other question from Justin: Abner's ICLA should have been filed under "Abner Ferreira" as the public name, are they findable under that name?
-David On Mon, Jul 18, 2022, at 10:42, David Li wrote: > The contributors are all (sub)contractors of Dremio, who were retained to > work on this project. I checked with the lead author (Kyle Porter) and he > confirmed all IP is with Dremio, who filed the software grant - is that what > we're looking to confirm? A CCLA was not filed with Apache, as we followed a > similar process to a prior grant from Dremio [1]. Unless you mean the > agreement between the contributors and Dremio? > > [1]: https://lists.apache.org/thread/w3btsx6l8gf0ognds8b6bng1ng4ccg00 > > -David > > On 2022/07/18 04:58:00 Daniel Widdis wrote: > > Thanks for the clarity, David. > > > > Given the clear "commit trail" for individual committers and the ICLAs I > > don't see a problem there. I think the only question that may need a bit > > more clarity is the relationship of Dremio to the contributions. I know my > > own employer has boilerplate legal claims on any open source work I do > > using company equipment or during "working hours" but there is also a > > process to allow/approve contributions. > > > > Can you elaborate on any corporate relationship to the contributions and if > > there is a process for open source contributions, particularly if the > > contributors used corporate computers or labor, and whether this is > > addressed in the CCLA? > > > > On 7/17/22, 8:15 PM, "David Li" <li...@apache.org> wrote: > > > > Hello, > > > > Sorry for some of the confusion here, I'll try to explain. (Apologies > > if this does not get linked back up correctly to the thread - Pony Mail > > does not let me login and the mailto: link generates a URL which is too > > long). > > > > I did preemptively ask the contributors to add the Apache license > > boilerplate before final submission, so apologies for the confusion there. > > The original files as I recall either had the header or did not have any > > header. > > > > There was a short discussion on the Arrow dev@ list at [1] where we > > decided to go through the IP clearance process to make sure everything was > > clear, since when the PR was first submitted, it had been developed for a > > long time outside the community (with commits dating back to 2020, although > > the PR was submitted in 2022). > > > > I believe Abner submitted an ICLA. I will re-confirm with the authors > > (I can't appear to view this information myself on the Apache side). > > > > [1]: https://lists.apache.org/thread/xytqttpov1d3q9mhd6nrlz7xkl7q5zjp > > > > Hopefully this helps, > > David > > > > > > > > --------------------------------------------------------------------- > > To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscr...@incubator.apache.org > > For additional commands, e-mail: general-h...@incubator.apache.org > > > >
