On 20.05.2015 00:44, Justin Mclean wrote:
> Hi,
>
> +0 (binding) from me until these 2 issues are resolved. Of course other IPMC
> members may vote differently.
>
> Several bundled files have GPL license headers e.g. ./ipc/shmem/config.guess,
> ./ipc/shmem/ltmain.sh etc. While these look like auto generated build files
> but I'm not sure that they can be included in a source release.
There's no way around including such files; any normal (i.e., not Java
:) source package that uses configure and libtool needs those files
bundled in the source.
However, I'll have to vote -1: the LICENSE, NOTICE and DEPENDENCIES
files shouldn't be in the package. They appear to be some maven side
effect. Especially LICENSE and NOTICE are confusing because a user has
no way to be sure which file she should be reading.
Other issues:
* The "official" source for "official convenience" binaries should be
the source package, not some tag in the repository. The source
package is what we release; not the repository contents. I'm sure I
mentioned that before.
* I agree with Justin about binary package placing and naming; you'll
recall that I was quite eloquent on that topic a while ago, without
much effect.
* There are many, many HTML syntax errors in the javadocs.
* Once finally run, the node says "New version is available at
ignite.incubator.apache.org: 1.0.0". Surely that's a bug if I'm
running 1.1.0?
Finally, I apologize for not bringing these issues up on the PPMC vote
thread; I was sidetracked by other issues the last couple weeks.
-- Brane
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscr...@incubator.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: general-h...@incubator.apache.org
