+1 (binding) On Tue, Feb 5, 2013 at 8:24 AM, Andrew Hart <ah...@apache.org> wrote:
> +1 (binding) > > -Andrew > > > > On 2/5/13 8:18 AM, Mattmann, Chris A (388J) wrote: > >> Hi Folks, >> >> OK, now that discussion has settled down, I'd like to call a VOTE for >> acceptance of Apache Open Climate Workbench into the Incubator. >> I'll leave the VOTE open the rest of the week and close it out next >> Monday, February 11th early am PT. >> >> [ ] +1 Accept Apache Open Climate Workbench into the Incubator >> [ ] +0 Don't care. >> [ ] -1 Don't accept Apache Open Climate Workbench into the Incubator >> because... >> >> Full proposal is pasted at the bottom of this email. Only VOTEs from >> Incubator PMC members are binding, but all are welcome to express their >> thoughts. >> >> Thank you! >> >> Cheers, >> Chris >> >> P.S. Here's my +1 (binding) >> >> ------------- >> = Apache Open Climate Workbench, tool for scalable comparison of remote >> sensing observations to climate model outputs, regionally and globally. = >> === Abstract === >> The Apache Open Climate Workbench proposal desires to contribute an >> existing community of software related to the analysis and evaluation of >> climate models, and related to the use of remote sensing data in that >> process. >> >> Specifically, we will bring a fundamental software toolkit for analysis >> and evaluation of climate model output against remote sensing data. The >> toolkit is called the [[http://rcmes.jpl.nasa.gov|**Regional Climate >> Model >> Evaluation System (RCMES)]]. RCMES provides two fundamental components for >> the easy, intuitive comparison of climate model output against remote >> sensing data. The first component called RCMED (for "Regional Climate >> Model Evaluation Database") is a scalable cloud database that decimates >> remote sensing data and renalysis data related to climate using Apache >> OODT extractors, Apache Tika, etc. These transformations make >> traditionally heterogeneous upstream remote sensing data and climate model >> output homogeneous and unify them into a data point model of the form >> (lat, lng, time, value, height) on a per parameter basis. Latitude (lat) >> and Longitude (lng) are in WGS84 format, but can be reformatted on the >> fly. time is in ISO 8601 format, a string sortable format independent of >> underlying store. value carries with it units, related to interpretation >> and height allows for different values for different atmospheric vertical >> levels. All of RCMES is built on Apache OODT, Apache Sqoop/Apache Hadoop >> and Apache Hive, along with hooks to PostGIS and MySQL (traditional >> relational databases). The second component of the system, RCMET (for >> "Regional Climate Model Evaluation Toolkit") provides facilities for >> connecting to RCMED, dynamically obtaining remote sensing data for a >> space/time region of interest, grabbing associated model output (that the >> user brings, or from the Earth System Grid Federation) of the same form, >> and then regridding the remote sensing data to be on the model output >> grid, or the model output to be on the remote sensing data grid. The >> regridded data spatially is then temporally regridded using techniques >> including seasonal cycle compositing (e.g., all summer months, all >> Januaries, etc.), or by daily, monthly, etc. The uniform model output and >> remote sensing data are then analyzed using pluggable metrics, e.g., >> Probability Distribution Functions (PDFs), Root Mean Squared Error (RMSE), >> Bias, and other (possibly user-defined) techniques, computing an analyzed >> comparison or evaluation. This evaluation is then visualized by plugging >> in to the NCAR NCL library for producing static plots (histograms, time >> series, etc.) >> >> We also have performed a great deal of work in packaging RCMES to make the >> system easy to deploy. We have working Virtual Machines (VMWare VMX and >> Virtual Box OVA compatible formats) and we also have an installer built on >> Python Buildout (http://buildout.org/) called "Easy RCMET" for >> dynamically >> constructing the RCMET toolkit. >> >> RCMES is currently supporting a number of recognized climate projects of >> (inter-)national significance. In particular, RCMES is supporting the >> [[http://www.globalchange.gov/**what-we-do/assessment|U.S<http://www.globalchange.gov/what-we-do/assessment%7CU.S>. >> National Climate >> Assessment (NCA) activities]] on behalf of NASA's contribution to the NCA; >> is working with the >> [[http://www.narccap.ucar.edu/**|North<http://www.narccap.ucar.edu/%7CNorth>American >> Regional >> Climate Change Assessment Program (NARCCAP)]]; and is also working with >> the International >> [[http://wcrp-cordex.ipsl.**jussieu.fr/|Coordinated<http://wcrp-cordex.ipsl.jussieu.fr/%7CCoordinated> >> Regional Downscaling Experiment (CORDEX)]]. >> >> === Proposal === >> We propose to transition the RCMES software community, which includes >> developers of the RCMET and RCMED software, along with users of RCMES in >> the CORDEX project across a variety of academic institutions, scientists >> helping to improve the RCMES metrics, and visualizations, and regridding >> algorithms, packagers making RCMES easier to install, and scientists >> helping to lead some of these international projects that are already >> using RCMES. >> >> We have been working on the RCMES project since 2009 funded initially by >> the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (ARRA) project out at NASA, and >> then branching out into other sources of support and sustainability (NASA; >> NSF, etc. -- see the >> [[http://rcmes.jpl.nasa.gov/**about/overview|**acknowledgements<http://rcmes.jpl.nasa.gov/about/overview%7Cacknowledgements>]] >> section on >> the RCMES website for a full list of supporting U.S. and international >> partners). >> >> With the existing RCMES community at Apache, we will also work to >> encourage other climate software projects e.g., Open Climate GIS, elements >> of the Earth System Grid Federation, other NASA climate projects funded >> under the Computational Modeling, Algorithms and Cyberinfrastructure >> (CMAC) to contribute to the Open Climate Workbench here at Apache. >> >> RCMED is a Big Data project that combines several underlying Apache >> software -- OODT, Tika, Hadoop, HIVE, and Sqoop -- and other related data >> management software. Its primary language is Java; RCMET, on the other >> hand, is a Python API, associated set of classes (framework), set of >> Python Bottle Web services, and a PHP "Wizard"-based User Interface that >> leverages Apache OODT Balance. >> >> === Background === >> Bringing RCMES to Apache was the brain-child of Chris Mattmann, based on >> his solid experience with Apache OODT and bringing it to the ASF. Chris >> worked for a year to get the support of the JPL community including >> approvals from the Software Release authority at JPL to release the >> software. >> >> The initial code drop will include the RCMES SVN repository from JPL >> including prior revisions. We anticipate also including a smaller package, >> CDX, which contains some useful facilities for regridding, and command >> line tools for manipulating large datasets, and working with OPeNDAP, etc. >> >> After the code drop, we will work with our developers, users, documentors, >> and other members of the team to teach those unfamiliar with the Apache >> way how it works around here at Apache. 30% of the community from RCMES >> includes those intimately familiar with Apache including 6 ASF members -- >> the other 70% include a range of scientific code developers, climate >> scientists that use RCMES, program officers that will help make >> documentation and slides for the code, and advocate for it in the >> community. Their experience with Apache ranges from using various ASF >> products, to contributing patches to them, to not using any ASF software >> at all. >> >> With this diversity, we anticipate that while everything may not just work >> turnkey out of the box, this represents a unique opportunity to >> demonstrate Apache to the international community and to show the benefits >> of its community and social models. That said, we also have a lot of ASF >> experience to make sure everyone learns the Apache way. >> >> === Rationale === >> We are bringing RCMES to Apache for a few reasons. First, we feel that it >> will immediately enable our collaborators across a number of institutions >> both nationally and internationally have the opportunity to work on a >> common software base, and to improve it with contributions from their own >> sites. Currently these are difficult to negotiate now because of varied >> legal and contribution frameworks -- Apache allows us to simplify this to >> a unified one. Second, using the ASF's world-wide mirroring system, we >> will be able to deliver climate software broadly to the community as we >> release it, rather than sneaker netting the software around or >> establishing our own point release infrastructure. >> >> Bringing this project to Apache also immediately thrusts the ASF into the >> thriving ecosystem of the Coordinated Regional Downscaling Experiment >> (CORDEX), the US National Cimate Assessment, the North American Regional >> Climate Change Assessment Program (the US contribution to CORDEX) and into >> relevance for upcoming Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) >> assessment activities at a number of different institutions. We also seek >> to help lead and encourage du jour standard development rather than top >> down level dictating of standards for climate software and the ASF will >> provide us a means for that. >> >> === Initial Goals === >> The initial goals of the proposed project are: >> >> * Stand up a sustaining Apache-based community around the JPL RCMES >> codebase. >> * Active relationships and possible cooperation with related projects >> and >> communities, including end user and scientific communities, CORDEX, >> NARCCAP, US NCA, IPCC, ESG, etc. >> * Active relationships and possible cooperation with existing Apache >> communities, e.g., OODT, Hadoop/HIVE, Sqoop, Tika, SIS, etc. >> * Initial Apache release. >> * Leverage Apache Open Climate Workbench in climate activities at NASA, >> in the international community as mentioned above, and beyond. >> * Vetting all software licenses and making sure IP is clear (software >> grant from JPL forthcoming). >> == Current Status == >> === Meritocracy === >> 30% of the proposed initial committers are familiar with the meritocracy >> principles of Apache. As stated above this includes 6 ASF members. Of the >> mentorship list, we have included Chris Douglas, a PMC member from Hadoop >> and ASF member to help guide the community. Chris M. and Chris D. have >> guided a number of projects through the Incubator over the years. The >> other mentor includes Paul Ramirez, who has experience with the Incubator >> -- he was a mentor for Apache Any23, and also was one of the PPMC members >> and eventual mentor for Apache SIS. The 70% of proposed initial committers >> that aren't as familiar with Apache have a broad range of experience in >> other open source projects, and have a deep respect and affinity for the >> foundation and the work that gets done here. The more experience ASF >> mentors and project members will help to guide them. >> === Community === >> There is an existing, established community of developers and users of >> this projet. This includes established communities including the >> Coordinated Regional Downscaling Experiment, the U.S. National Climate >> Assessment (NCA), the North American Regional Climate Change Assessment >> Program (NARCCAP), and more. The Coordinated Regional Climate Downscaling >> Experiment (CORDEX, >> http://wcrp.ipsl.jussieu.fr/**cordex/about.html<http://wcrp.ipsl.jussieu.fr/cordex/about.html>) >> is a >> world wide effort of coordination of regional climate downscaling (RCD) >> experiments driven by the World Climate Research Program (WRCP, >> http://www.wcrp-climate.org/**index.shtml<http://www.wcrp-climate.org/index.shtml>). >> Recently, a large number of RCD >> projects have been carried out on a large parts of the world. To maximize >> the benefits of these research activities the WCRP designed a framework >> (Giorgi, WMO-Bulletin, 2009) focused on "quality-control [of] data sets of >> RCD-based information for the recent historical past and 21st century >> projections, covering the majority of populated land regions on the >> globe". CORDEX defined different control domains (up to 10, >> http://cordex.dmi.dk/joomla/) for almost all the populated regions of the >> world in a way to standardize the experiments and make them comparable. A >> key region focused on Africa was also designated as the top priority by >> WRCP. CORDEX also provides a a series of conventions and list of variables >> that have to be followed by any project that wants to contribute to the >> experiment. Each CORDEX region has a coordinator and regional and >> international periodic meetings are scheduled in a way to ensure the >> global well being. NARCCAP is the U.S. contribution to CORDEX. From the >> [[http://www.globalchange.gov/**what-we-do/assessment/nca-**overview|US<http://www.globalchange.gov/what-we-do/assessment/nca-overview%7CUS> >> National Climate Assessment]] site, work is "being conducted under the >> auspices of the Global Change Research Act of 1990. The GCRA requires a >> report to the President and the Congress every four years that integrates, >> evaluates, and interprets the findings of the U.S. Global Change Research >> Program (USGCRP); analyzes the effects of global change on the natural >> environment, agriculture, energy production and use, land and water >> resources, transportation, human health and welfare, human social systems, >> and biological diversity; and analyzes current trends in global change, >> both human-induced and natural, and projects major trends for the >> subsequent 25 to 100 years." >> >> Apache Open Climate Workbench will support all of these communities above, >> with an eye towards being a general purpose climate evaluation toolkit for >> model output and remote sensing data. >> >> === Core Developers === >> The initial set of developers comes from various NASA centers (JPL, and >> Goddard Space Flight Center), NASA HQ, various Universities participating >> in CORDEX (Cape Town, University of New South Wales), the Indian Institute >> of Tropical Meteorology, the Free Univ. Berlin), the University of >> California Los Angeles, and Howard University. As mentioned previously >> several of our developers are Apache veterans and understand how it works >> around here and for those that don't, they will have great mentorship. >> >> === Alignment === >> Our proposed effort aligns with the U.S. National Climate Assessment, the >> CORDEX effort, other efforts, including the Earth System Grid Federation, >> other climate software including the Open Climate GIS toolkit, other >> science portals for climate including the Climate Information Portal (CIP) >> at the University of Cape Town, and other related projects. >> >> There are also a number of related Apache projects and dependencies, that >> will be mentioned in the Relationships with Other Apache products section. >> >> == Known Risks == >> === Orphaned products === >> Our project has a history of funding support from JPL, NASA (Applications >> program/ARRA, NCA, AIST), NSF (ExArch project), international investment >> from collaborators, and from other funding sources. The funding sources >> are all target future deliverables and activities, so there is little >> chance this software and community will be orphaned. >> >> === Inexperience with Open Source === >> All the initial developers have worked on open source before -- 30% of the >> proposed initial community are experience with the ASF, and are PMC >> members and committers on ASF project including 6 ASF members. Our mentors >> are all ASF members, and we welcome any interest from additional Apache >> mentors in the effort. Those 70% of our project that aren't Apache >> committers, PMC members, or members will benefit from the leadership of >> the other 30% of the project. >> >> === Homogenous Developers === >> The initial developers come from a variety of backgrounds and with a >> variety of needs for the proposed framework. Everyone is used to >> communicating on mailing lists as the project spans timezones, >> international institutions and centers of excellence for climate science. >> >> === Reliance on Salaried Developers === >> All of the proposed initial developers are paid to work on this or related >> projects, but the proposed project is not the primary task for anyone. >> >> === Relationships with Other Apache Products === >> As mentioned above, RCMES and the Apache Open Climate Workbench already >> depend on Apache OODT for facade interfaces to underlying data warehouses >> for storing remote sensing data; and for metadata extraction and >> transformation. The software also uses Apache Tika for this (through a >> transitive dependency from OODT). In addition, we have hooks to Apache >> Hadoop/HIVE, as well as dependencies on Apache Sqoop for dumping out >> remote sensing data from MySQL and into HIVE. >> >> === A Excessive Fascination with the Apache Brand === >> All of us are familiar with Apache and have a respect for its brand and >> community. Chris Mattmann is a big proponent of Apache's sustainability >> factor -- and it's ability to grow software communities, in an >> institution, or funding source neutral manner. All of the community have >> an extreme respect for Apache, including those in our communities who >> aren't necessarily trained computer scientists, but are Scientists (big >> "S", e.g., land, physical, Earth/Climate scientists). >> >> == Documentation == >> The initial RCMES code base will come from the internal JPL Subversion >> repository. The [[Regional Climate Model Evaluation System (RCMES) >> project|http://rcmes.jpl.nasa.**gov <http://rcmes.jpl.nasa.gov>]] at >> [[JPL|http://www.jpl.nasa.gov/**]] >> has documentation on the existing software, including links to funding >> support, communities, and other projects. We will continue to maintain >> that site at JPL, which is part of the reason for rebranding the project >> here at Apache with a new name to not interfere with the existing RCMES >> one that has a following. In addition, we hope to evolve RCMES@JPL to >> have >> increasing levels of dependency on Apache Open Climate Workbench, so that >> we can incrementally transition with little impact to existing customers. >> >> In addition, JPL's [[http://cdx.jpl.nasa.gov|**Climate Data eXchange >> (CDX)]] >> website also has documentation on the existing software. >> >> == Initial Source == >> The project will start with seed code donated by NASA JPL via Mattmann and >> the rest of the initial committers, which consists of the Regional Climate >> Model Evaluation System (RCMES) toolkit, and the Climate Data eXchange >> (CDX) software. This will include the core Python API for RCMET, the RCMED >> OODT catalog project (which stores remote sensing data to MySQL/PostGIS, >> and HIVE), and the RCMED extractors for various climate formats. The >> source will also include Easy-RCMET, the Python Buildout for RCMET. In >> addition, we will bring along the CDX toolkit, which includes a CDX client >> package that performs subsetting, access, regridding of climate data; and >> also includes a Python Buildout installer of its own called Uber CDX. >> >> == Source and Intellectual Property Submission Plan == >> All seed code and other contributions will be handled through the normal >> Apache contribution process. Mattmann has been authorized by NASA JPL to >> lead the contribution of RCMES and CDX into the Incubator via his existing >> Apache CLA, and a Software Grant to be provided. >> >> We will also contact other related efforts for possible cooperation and >> contributions. >> >> == External Dependencies == >> Our project depends on a number of external libraries with various >> licensing conditions. An initial list of such dependencies is shown below. >> ||<tableclass="bodyTable"**rowclass="b">'''Library''' ||'''License''' || >> ||<rowclass="b">[[http://www.**ncl.ucar.edu/|NCAR<http://www.ncl.ucar.edu/%7CNCAR>NCL]]||MIT >> compat|| >> ||<rowclass="a">[[http://www.**pyngl.ucar.edu/Nio.shtml|**PyNIO]]||MIT<http://www.pyngl.ucar.edu/Nio.shtml%7CPyNIO%5D%5D%7C%7CMIT>compat|| >> ||<rowclass="b">[[http://www.**pyngl.ucar.edu/|PyNGL]]||MIT<http://www.pyngl.ucar.edu/%7CPyNGL%5D%5D%7C%7CMIT>compat|| >> ||<rowclass="a">[[http://**matplotlib.sourceforge.net/|** >> Matplotlib]]||Modified<http://matplotlib.sourceforge.net/%7CMatplotlib%5D%5D%7C%7CModified> >> PSF license|| >> ||<rowclass="b">[[http://**scipy.org/|Scipy]]||MIT<http://scipy.org/%7CScipy%5D%5D%7C%7CMIT>compat|| >> ||<rowclass="a">[[http://**numpy.scipy.org/|NumPy]]||MIT<http://numpy.scipy.org/%7CNumPy%5D%5D%7C%7CMIT>compat|| >> ||<rowclass="b">[[http://www.**hdfgroup.org/HDF5/|HDF5]]||**BSD||<http://www.hdfgroup.org/HDF5/%7CHDF5%5D%5D%7C%7CBSD%7C%7C> >> ||<rowclass="a">[[http://www.**unidata.ucar.edu/software/** >> netcdf/|NetCDF]]||MI<http://www.unidata.ucar.edu/software/netcdf/%7CNetCDF%5D%5D%7C%7CMI> >> T|| >> >> >> == Cryptography == >> The project itself will not use cryptography, but it is possible that some >> of the external software libraries will include cryptographic code to >> handle features present in various science data formats. If we need to >> provide an export control statement regarding cryptographic code per >> Apache policy, we will follow a similar approach by Mattmann in >> [[http://lucene.apache.org/**nutch/|Apache<http://lucene.apache.org/nutch/%7CApache>Nutch]] >> and by Jukka Zitting lead >> this effort in Apache Tika. Mattmann is familiar with this process. >> >> == Required Resources == >> Mailing lists >> >> * dev@climate.incubator.apache.**org <d...@climate.incubator.apache.org> >> * >> commits@climate.incubator.**apache.org<comm...@climate.incubator.apache.org> >> * >> private@climate.incubator.**apache.org<priv...@climate.incubator.apache.org> >> >> Subversion Directory >> >> * >> https://svn.apache.org/repos/**asf/incubator/climate<https://svn.apache.org/repos/asf/incubator/climate> >> >> Issue Tracking >> >> * JIRA CLIMATE (CLIMATE) >> >> Other Resources >> >> * CLIMATE Wiki >> http://cwiki.apache.org/**CLIMATE<http://cwiki.apache.org/CLIMATE> >> * Review Board instance - CLIMATE >> * Jenkins instance - CLIMATE >> >> == Initial Committers == >> ||'''Name''' ||'''Email''' ||'''Affiliation''' ||'''CLA''' || >> ||Chris A. Mattmann ||mattmann at apache dot org >> ||[[http://www.jpl.nasa.gov/|**NASA <http://www.jpl.nasa.gov/%7CNASA>Jet >> Propulsion Laboratory]] ||yes || >> ||Cameron E. Goodale ||goodale at apache dot org >> ||[[http://www.jpl.nasa.gov/|**NASA <http://www.jpl.nasa.gov/%7CNASA>Jet >> Propulsion Laboratory]] ||yes || >> ||Paul Ramirez ||pramirez at apache dog org >> ||[[http://www.jpl.nasa.gov/|**NASA <http://www.jpl.nasa.gov/%7CNASA>Jet >> Propulsion Laboratory]] ||yes || >> ||Andrew F. Hart ||ahart at apache dot org >> ||[[http://www.jpl.nasa.gov/|**NASA <http://www.jpl.nasa.gov/%7CNASA>Jet >> Propulsion Laboratory]] ||yes || >> ||Jinwon Kim||jkim at atmos dot ucla dot edu >> ||[[http://jifresse.ucla.edu|**UCLA Joint Institute for Regional Earth >> System Science and Engineering]] || no|| >> ||Duane Waliser||duane dot waliser at jpl dot nasa dot gov >> ||[[http://www.jpl.nasa.gov/|**NASA <http://www.jpl.nasa.gov/%7CNASA>Jet >> Propulsion Laboratory]] || no || >> ||Huikyo Lee||Huikyo dot Lee at jpl dot nasa dot >> gov||[[http://www.jpl.nasa.**gov/|NASA <http://www.jpl.nasa.gov/%7CNASA>Jet >> Propulsion Laboratory]] || no || >> ||Paul Loikith|| Paul dot C dot Loikith at jpl dot nasa dot gov >> ||[[http://www.jpl.nasa.gov/|**NASA <http://www.jpl.nasa.gov/%7CNASA>Jet >> Propulsion Laboratory]] || no || >> ||Daniel J. Crichton||crichton at apache dot >> org||[[http://www.jpl.nasa.**gov/|NASA <http://www.jpl.nasa.gov/%7CNASA>Jet >> Propulsion Laboratory]] || yes || >> ||Kim Whitehall||Kim dot D dot Whitehall at jpl dot nasa dot gov >> ||[[http://www.physics1.**howard.edu/~pmisra/HUPAS/** >> HUPAS/HUPAS%20Jenkins.html<http://www.physics1.howard.edu/~pmisra/HUPAS/HUPAS/HUPAS%20Jenkins.html> >> |Howard University]] || no || >> ||Paul Zimdars||pzimdars at apache dot >> org||[[http://www.jpl.nasa.**gov/|NASA <http://www.jpl.nasa.gov/%7CNASA>Jet >> Propulsion Laboratory]] || yes || >> ||Chris Jack||cjack at csag dot uct dot ac dot >> za||[[http://www.csag.uct.ac.**za/|University<http://www.csag.uct.ac.za/%7CUniversity>of >> Cape Town]] || no || >> ||Bruce Hewitson||hewitson at csag dot uct dot ac dot >> za||[[http://www.csag.uct.ac.**za/|University<http://www.csag.uct.ac.za/%7CUniversity>of >> Cape Town]] || no || >> ||Lluis Fita Borrell||l dot fitaborrell at unsw dot edu dot >> au||[[http://unsw.edu.au/|**University <http://unsw.edu.au/%7CUniversity>of >> New South Wales]] || yes || >> ||Jason Evans||jason dot evans at unsw dot edu dot >> au||[[http://unsw.edu.au/|**University <http://unsw.edu.au/%7CUniversity>of >> New South Wales]] || no || >> ||Estani Gonzalez||estanislao dot gonzalez at met dot fu-berlin dot de >> ||[[http://www.geo.fu-berlin.**de/met/|Free<http://www.geo.fu-berlin.de/met/%7CFree>University >> Berlin]] || yes || >> ||Luca Cinquini||luca dot cinquini at jpl dot nasa dot gov >> ||[[http://www.jpl.nasa.gov/|**NASA <http://www.jpl.nasa.gov/%7CNASA>Jet >> Propulsion Laboratory]] || yes || >> ||J. Sanjay||sanjay at tropmet dot res dot in || >> [[http://tropmet.res.in/|**Indian <http://tropmet.res.in/%7CIndian>Institute >> of Tropical Meteorology]] || yes >> || >> ||M. V. S. Rama Rao||ramarao at tropmet dot res dot in >> ||[[http://tropmet.res.in/|**Indian >> <http://tropmet.res.in/%7CIndian>Institute of Tropical Meteorology]] || >> yes || >> ||Tsengdar Lee||tsengdar dot j dot lee at nasa dot gov || >> [[http://hq.nassa.gov/|NASA HQ]] || no || >> ||Laura Carriere||laura dot carriere at nasa dot gov >> ||[[http://www.gsfc.nasa.gov/|**NASA >> <http://www.gsfc.nasa.gov/%7CNASA>Goddard Space Flight Center]] || no || >> ||Denis Nadeau|| denis dot nadeau at nasa dot >> gov||[[http://www.gsfc.nasa.**gov/|NASA<http://www.gsfc.nasa.gov/%7CNASA>Goddard >> Space Flight Center]] || no >> || >> ||Michael Joyce|| Michael dot J dot Joyce at jpl dot nasa dot >> gov||[[http://www.jpl.nasa.**gov/|NASA <http://www.jpl.nasa.gov/%7CNASA>Jet >> Propulsion Laboratory]] ||yes|| >> ||Shakeh Khudikyan||Shakeh dot E dot Khudikyan at jpl dot nasa dot >> gov||[[http://www.jpl.nasa.**gov/|NASA <http://www.jpl.nasa.gov/%7CNASA>Jet >> Propulsion Laboratory]] ||yes|| >> ||Maziyar Boustani||Maziyar dot Boustani at jpl dot nasa dot >> gov||[[http://www.jpl.nasa.**gov/|NASA <http://www.jpl.nasa.gov/%7CNASA>Jet >> Propulsion Laboratory]] ||no|| >> ||Suresh Marru||smarru at apache dot >> org||[[http://pti.iu.edu/|**Indiana<http://pti.iu.edu/%7CIndiana> >> University]] ||yes|| >> >> >> == Sponsors == >> Champion >> >> * Chris Mattmann (mattmann at apache dot org) >> >> Nominated Mentors >> >> * Chris A. Mattmann (mattmann at apache dot org) >> * Chris Douglas (cdouglas at apache dot org) >> * Paul Ramirez (pramirez at apache dot org) >> >> Sponsoring Entity >> >> * Apache Incubator >> >> >> >> ------------------------------**------------------------------**--------- >> To unsubscribe, e-mail: >> general-unsubscribe@incubator.**apache.org<general-unsubscr...@incubator.apache.org> >> For additional commands, e-mail: >> general-help@incubator.apache.**org<general-h...@incubator.apache.org> >> >> > > -- > Andrew F. Hart > http://people.apache.org/~**ahart <http://people.apache.org/~ahart> > > > > ------------------------------**------------------------------**--------- > To unsubscribe, e-mail: > general-unsubscribe@incubator.**apache.org<general-unsubscr...@incubator.apache.org> > For additional commands, e-mail: > general-help@incubator.apache.**org<general-h...@incubator.apache.org> > >
