Salut Marcel/all,
> So either all of these packages are "wrong" or it seems it is
> acceptable usage. Actually I think it is fine: it is the only folder
> which becomes extracted for me everything inside this folder is
> "root".
+1, and I'd invite you reconsidering to change the -1 vote to a +1:
inspecting the org.apache:apache:12 it clearly shows the same
structure of org.apache.onami:org.apache.onami.parent:1-incubating
* with unzip:
$ unzip -l apache-12-source-release.zip
Archive: apache-12-source-release.zip
Length Date Time Name
-------- ---- ---- ----
0 11-01-12 22:57 apache-12/
0 11-01-12 22:57 apache-12/src/
0 11-01-12 22:57 apache-12/src/site-docs/
0 11-01-12 22:57 apache-12/src/site-docs/apt/
15519 11-01-12 22:57 apache-12/pom.xml
2759 11-01-12 22:57 apache-12/site-pom.xml
6265 11-01-12 22:57 apache-12/src/site-docs/apt/index.apt
2233 11-01-12 22:57 apache-12/src/site-docs/site.xml
280 11-01-12 22:57 apache-12/DEPENDENCIES
11358 11-01-12 22:57 apache-12/LICENSE
182 11-01-12 22:57 apache-12/NOTICE
-------- -------
38596 11 files
* with jar:
$ jar tf apache-12-source-release.zip
apache-12/
apache-12/src/
apache-12/src/site-docs/
apache-12/src/site-docs/apt/
apache-12/pom.xml
apache-12/site-pom.xml
apache-12/src/site-docs/apt/index.apt
apache-12/src/site-docs/site.xml
apache-12/DEPENDENCIES
apache-12/LICENSE
apache-12/NOTICE
moreover, the org.apache.onami:org.apache.onami.parent:1-incubating
zip archive has built with the
org.apache.apache.resources:apache-source-release-assembly-descriptor:1.0.4
:)
>> It should only be in the notice if Onami contains third-party software that
>> requires you mention it [1]. Since this is code that was donated to Apache,
>> I don't think that applies, so you should leave it out.
>
> Makes sense to me too. Do you consider it a blocker?
It is not a blocker and should be tolerable/acceptable, since previous
maintainers have already been mentioned in NOTICE file, see Any23's
NOTICE[1].
TIA!
-Simo
[1] http://svn.apache.org/repos/asf/any23/trunk/NOTICE.txt
http://people.apache.org/~simonetripodi/
http://simonetripodi.livejournal.com/
http://twitter.com/simonetripodi
http://www.99soft.org/
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscr...@incubator.apache.org
For additional commands, e-mail: general-h...@incubator.apache.org
