On May 26, 2012, at 9:29 PM, Arvind Prabhakar wrote: > Hi Jukka, > > On Sat, May 26, 2012 at 4:43 PM, Jukka Zitting <jukka.zitt...@gmail.com>wrote: >> >> IIUC Flume operates under an RTC model where people are not supposed >> to commit their own changes, which obviously makes the above data less >> relevant for evaluating the true diversity of the community. However, >> seeing only a single trivial commit by both jarcec and juhanic even >> though they became committers already over three months ago does seem >> to suggest that they may not be as comfortable in their committer role >> as people from Cloudera are. >> > > As you noted in your comments above - the Flume project tends to follow RTC > with the reviewer committing the code. I happen to have taken up the role > of the reviewer for the most part and hence you see the skewed commit > counts. If you want to see the actual contribution, I would suggest looking > at fixed JIRA issues by assignees. A quick report yields the following: > > aprabhkar - 26 - Cloudera [6] > brocknoland - 19 - Cloudera [7] > esammer - 56 - Cloudera [8] > hshreedharan - 34 - Cloudera [9] > jarcec - 6 - AVG Technologies [10] > jmhsieh - 8 - Cloudera [11] > juhanic - 9 - CyberAgent [12] > mpercy - 34 - Cloudera [13] > m...@apache.org - 1 - Trend Micro [14] > prasadm - 34 - Cloudera [15] > t...@cloudera.com - 3 - Cloudera [16] > w...@cloudera.com - 3 - Cloudera [17] > > Looking at this, the average number of issues resolved by Cloudera > committers (not counting Tom who is a mentor) is 26, and that for > non-Cloudera committers is 5. Note that this number does not include other > committer work such as the number of code reviews they have done, the > number of design discussions they have participated in, something that is > very valuable to the project.
Another way of looking at these same statistics: Cloudera - 217 Other - 16 That means Cloudera is responsible for over 93% of the Jira issues. It is great that Cloudera is doing so much work but those stats hardly prove diversity. Ralph --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscr...@incubator.apache.org For additional commands, e-mail: general-h...@incubator.apache.org
