>> > [ ] +1 Accept Cassandra as a new podling >> > [ ] -1 Do not accept the new podling (provide reason, please) >> >> -1 (binding). >> >> I will even give reasons because it is Christmas; >> a. See Martijn's concern. >> b. Running vote over Christmas when *many* people are busy with other >> things. >> c. I would like to see a proposal with more "meat" in it. Some >> history, more elaboration on the various topics that the template >> provides... >> > > Just a different perspective: > > a) I agree with the concern but as Martijn expressed, I'm not sure it > should be a real concern for the vote. If the project dies, so be it. But > clearly a few individuals seem to care so why not giving them a chance? > b) +1 on this one, it could just be balanced by setting a longer than usual > voting time frame. > c) I agree although some feedback has been provided on the ML, it could be > nice to bring back some of that in the proposal.
Some thoughts from this end: I also have the feeling that the proposal could benefit from some more "meat". The timing around Christmas indeed was not very helpful either. But what really concerns me a bit is the question whether people really want to/can work together. It seems like the fork / non-fork debate already left some scars and I am not eager to invest time when people can't get along even to begin with. Maybe my "Avalon" alarm is set a little too sensitive but for now I only vote +0. Ian, since you are the one driving this... would you mind working with the project team on improving the proposal? ...and then consider a re-submit? cheers ...and Merry Christmas -- Torsten --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscr...@incubator.apache.org For additional commands, e-mail: general-h...@incubator.apache.org
