Tallying the results (in the order that Thunderbird sorted them), we had +1 from Geir, Dims, Robert, Noel, Jean, Sanjiva, Greg, Paul, Cliff, Ted, Tim, Craig, Leo, Yoav, Bill, Ken, Matthias, David, Niall, Roy

Note that Justin and Sam voted in other threads (as well as on the board vote :). If I left anyone else off of this list, I apologize.

So with that, and with board approval granted, The Incubator PMC graduates the Harmony podling.

Thanks all for the patience - I do think we have some things to chat about :)

geir

try {
  transaction.begin();
  getIncubatorApproval(transaction);
  getBoardApproval(transaction);
  transaction.commit();
}
catch(RollbackException re) {
  continueIncubation();
}


Geir Magnusson Jr. wrote:
The Apache Harmony community has voted to request graduation
from the Incubator as a TLP.

     <http://mail-archives.apache.org/mod_mbox/incubator-harmony-dev/
          200610.mbox/[EMAIL PROTECTED]>

The following votes have been recorded (in order of votes cast) :

   +1  Geir Magnusson Jr     (Incubator PMC/committer/mentor)
   +1  Etienne Gagnon
   +1  Gregory Shimansky     (committer)
   +1  Sam Ruby              (Incubator PMC)
   +1  Rana Dasgupta
   +1  Danese Cooper
   +1  Mark Hindess          (committer)
   +1  Alex Blewitt
   +1  Mikhail Fursov
   +1  Matthias Wessendorf
   +1  Alexei A Fedotov
   +1  Jorden Justen
   +1  Andrew Zhang
   +1  Leo Li
   +1  Nathan Beyer          (committer)
   +1  Naveen Neelakantam
   +1  Mikhail Loenko        (committer)
   +1  Leo Simons            (Incubator PMC/mentor)
   +1  Paulex Yang           (committer)
   +1  Tim Ellison           (committer)
   +1  Salikh Zakirov
   +1  Alex Karasulu         (Incubator PMC)
   +1  Weldon Washburn       (committer)
   +1  Sergey Soldatov
   +1  Nadya Morozova
   +1  Robert Burrell Donkin (Incubator PMC)
   +1  Richard Liang         (committer)
   +1  Vladimir Ivanov
   +1  Dan Lydick            (committer)
   +1  Tony Wu
   +1  Spark Shen
   +1  Rui Hu
   +1  Pavel Rebriy
   +1  Pavel Ozhdikhin
   +1  Jimmy Jing
   +1  Xiao-Feng Li
   +1  Alexey A Ivanov
   +1  Pavel Pervov
   +1  Sian January
   +1  Pavel Afremov
   +1  Alexei Zakharov        (committer)
   +1  Stefano Mazzocchi      (Incubator PMC/mentor)
   +1  Davanum Srinivas       (Incubator PMC/mentor)
   +1  Svetlana Konovalova
   +1  Egor Pasko
   +1  Stepan Mishura         (committer)
   +1  Ilya Okomin

Under the Incubator process, Harmony must have a destination prior
to exiting incubation, which means the ASF Board must decide whether or
not create a TLP for Apache Harmony prior to the Incubator vote being
official.  However, I suspect that the board would want some indication
that we are ready to graduate first.

So, I am asking for a vote of the Incubator on graduation of Harmony
that is conditional on the board's approval of a TLP for that purpose.
This way we don't have to vote again after the board meeting on
Wednesday (or whenever the board considers the proposal).

Please send in your +1/0/-1 to approve/abstain/disapprove.

Status: <http://incubator.apache.org/projects/harmony.html>

Site: <http://incubator.apache.org/harmony/>

List: <http://mail-archives.apache.org/mod_mbox/incubator-harmony-dev/>

geir


---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]


---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to