Thanks. Looks like we are done here. I'll look out for the update. Regards, Elwyn
On Tue, 2011-02-22 at 15:12 -0500, [email protected] wrote: > Elwyn, > > A few more comments: > > > > > s3.1: The encoding of the PT values is not specified. > > > > > > It's a 3-bit binary field (e.g., 6 is encoded as 110). I don't see a > > > need to explain this. > > Maybe I am a bit pedantic here but it seems wise to be explicit about > > the encoding since the values are sparse and the RFC 4385 defines these > > bits as 'flags'. > > Ok, I'll point out that Figure 3 overlays a 3-bit binary PT field and a 1-bit > unused field on RFC 4385's 4 bits Flags field. > > > > RFC 3985 is the wrong reference - the Length field is specified in RFC > > > 4385, which > > > is cited at the beginning of s3.1. The Length field is only used when > > > the PW packet > > > is shorter than 64 bytes because Ethernet will pad such a packet out to > > > 64 bytes - the > > > Length field allows the additional padding to be stripped. When the > > > packet is 64 bytes > > > or longer, the Length field is set to zero. > > Actually RFC 4385 is also less than specific. > > I can expand on this Length field slightly in this draft, but keep in mind > that this is not causing PW interop problems in practice. > > > > The Length field does not impose a restriction smaller than the MTU - see > > > RFC 4385. > > In that case the paragraph: > > > > > A PW packet may contain one or more encoded FC Ordered sets [FC-BB- > > > 6]. The length field in the FC PW Control Word is used to indicate > > > the packet length when the PW packet contains multiple Ordered Sets. > > > > > is confusing as it implies that the Length field *always* tells you how > > many ordered sets are in the packet. > > > That sentence needs work, thanks for pointing it out. In almost all cases, > the number of ordered sets being sent is short enough that the Length field > is non-zero, but it looks like there's a MUST requirement in here that an FC > PW packet that carries ordered sets be less than 64 bytes long (would be > capable of handling at most 15 ordered sets). I'll add that. > > > > > s3.3: Discussion of FC PW Control Frames: How is the Length field in the > > > > Control Word used in this case? > > > > If it isn't used, how is the size of the frame determined? > > > > > > See RFC 4385. FC PW Control Frames are short enough that Length will > > > always be non-zero. > > Is a note about this a good idea? If they were longer do you just have > > to rely on the lower layer? Is there any protection against corruption? > > I'll add the statement that the Length field is always used for FC PW Control > frames. The answer for longer FC PW control frames is that one would rely > solely on lower layer checks, and there are . The underlying received packet > length is available from the PSN - the Length field is used to overcome an > Ethernet limitation that may change that length between sender and receiver. > > Thanks, > --David > > > -----Original Message----- > > From: Elwyn Davies [mailto:[email protected]] > > Sent: Sunday, February 20, 2011 9:34 AM > > To: Black, David > > Cc: [email protected]; [email protected] > > Subject: RE: [Gen-art] Gen-art LC review of draft-ietf-pwe3-fc-encap > > > > Hi, David. > > On Fri, 2011-02-18 at 23:44 -0500, [email protected] wrote: > > > Hi Elwyn, > > > > > > Thanks for reviewing this draft. > > .. and for the responses. > > > > > > > s3.1: The encoding of the PT values is not specified. > > > > > > It's a 3-bit binary field (e.g., 6 is encoded as 110). I don't see a > > > need to explain this. > > Maybe I am a bit pedantic here but it seems wise to be explicit about > > the encoding since the values are sparse and the RFC 4385 defines these > > bits as 'flags'. > > > > > > > Should an explicit error behaviour for control words with PT set to > > > > something > > > > other than 1,2, 4 or 6 be specified? > > > > > > Yes, but the valid PT values are 0, 1, 2 and 6. A packet with an invalid > > > PT value (3, 4, 5 or 7) > > needs to be discarded, as it's corrupt or otherwise invalid for the FC PW > > (cannot be turned into FC > > traffic or otherwise usefully processed). I'll add a sentence. > > > > > Fine. > > > > s3.1: I note that RFC 3985 fails to specify the unit of the Length > > > > parameter (presumably bytes/octets, but since it seems to be used in > > > > various different ways it might be application specific) and does not > > > > specify the encoding for the parameter. This specification propagates > > > > this omission. > > > > > > RFC 3985 is the wrong reference - the Length field is specified in RFC > > > 4385, which > > > is cited at the beginning of s3.1. The Length field is only used when > > > the PW packet > > > is shorter than 64 bytes because Ethernet will pad such a packet out to > > > 64 bytes - the > > > Length field allows the additional padding to be stripped. When the > > > packet is 64 bytes > > > or longer, the Length field is set to zero. > > Actually RFC 4385 is also less than specific. > > > > > > > s3.3: FC Frames: How is the Length field in the control word used here? > > > > > > See RFC 4385. > > > > > > > > > Are there constraints on the Payload Type for this case? > > > > > > Yes, PT=0 or PT=1. The other PT values are not for frames. I'll add a > > > sentence. > > > > > > > s3.3: Discussion of encoding of ordered sets: Is there an upper limit > > > > on the number of ordered sets in a single PW packet? > > > > > > Yes, the total PW packet size can't exceed the MTU. I'll add a sentence > > > that points > > > back to the MTU discussion in s3.2 . > > > > > > > This isn't made > > > > explicit but the size of the Length field which is supposed to be used > > > > for 'short packets' possibly restricts the number of ordered sets. If > > > > this is not the case how is the length specified if the total is more > > > > then 64 whatevers (see the comment above on s3.1). > > > > > > The Length field does not impose a restriction smaller than the MTU - see > > > RFC 4385. > > In that case the paragraph: > > > > > A PW packet may contain one or more encoded FC Ordered sets [FC-BB- > > > 6]. The length field in the FC PW Control Word is used to indicate > > > the packet length when the PW packet contains multiple Ordered Sets. > > > > > is confusing as it implies that the Length field *always* tells you how > > many ordered sets are in the packet. > > > > Overall the whole business of the packet length in PWE3 seems to be rather > > a mess (not the fault of the FC specification of course). So one is reliant > > on the lower layers to tell you the packet lenghth (sometimes). Hmm! > > > > > > > s3.3: Discussion of encoding of ordered sets: What payload types are > > > > allowed for this case? > > > > > > PT=2, I'll add a sentence. > > > > > > > s3.3: Discussion of FC PW Control Frames: How is the Length field in the > > > > Control Word used in this case? > > > > If it isn't used, how is the size of the frame determined? > > > > > > See RFC 4385. FC PW Control Frames are short enough that Length will > > > always be non-zero. > > Is a note about this a good idea? If they were longer do you just have > > to rely on the lower layer? Is there any protection against corruption? > > > > > > > Nits/editorial comments: > > > > > > If I make no comment below, I'll just fix it. > > Fine. Just one comment below. > > > > > > > Abstract/Section 1: For whatever reason the RFC Editor deems MPLS-TP to > > > > be a well-known abbreviation but not MPLS-TE.. so I guess MPLS-TE better > > > > be expanded. > > > > > > I'll just reduce this to MPLS-TP. > > > > > > > s1, next to last para: s/by comparison to/by comparison with (or in > > > > comparison to)/ > > > > > > > > s1.1, para 1: expand GFPT. > > > > > > > > s3: Is [FC-FS-2] a sufficient reference for the definition of 8b/10b > > > > encoding? I can't see the full text so I can't tell. There are lots of > > > > jargon items relating to 8b/10b later in s3. > > > > > > Yes, [FC-FS-2] is sufficient - let me know if you want a copy of FC-FS-2 > > > (I am authorized by T11 to send you one). > > I'll trust you on this one! :-) > > > > > > > s3: This section contains a number of FC jargon terms. Some of them (in > > > > the first set of bullet points - FC-SW, FC-P2P, FC-AL) are not expanded > > > > at all. Others in the second set of bullets (FLOGI, PLOGI, ELP) are > > > > expanded on second appearance a little lower down. Towards the end > > > > 10GFC and 16GFC may also need expansion or a reference. > > > > > > > > s3, next to last para: (just checking!) Is Service class F right? Others > > > > are numbers. > > > > > > Service class F is correct. The numbered service classes are end-to-end > > > in FC, whereas F is an > > inter-switch service class (F is for Fabric). > > > > > > > s3.3: Might be clearer if organized into three sub-sections for the > > > > three types of item transported. > > > > > > That makes sense, will do. > > > > > > > s3.3: A reference for the definitions of the FC Service Class 4 values > > > > mentioned (SOFi4, etc) is needed. > > > > > > It's [FC-FS-2] again - I'll add a citation. > > > > > > > s7, next to last para: RFC 3821 appears to prefer FCIP rather than FC/IP > > > > as an abbreviation. > > > > > > Ok. > > > > > > Thanks, > > > --David > > > ---------------------------------------------------- > > > David L. Black, Distinguished Engineer > > > EMC Corporation, 176 South St., Hopkinton, MA 01748 > > > +1 (508) 293-7953 FAX: +1 (508) 293-7786 > > > [email protected] Mobile: +1 (978) 394-7754 > > > ---------------------------------------------------- > > > > > > > -----Original Message----- > > > > From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]] On > > > > Behalf Of Elwyn Davies > > > > Sent: Wednesday, February 16, 2011 12:59 PM > > > > To: General Area Review Team > > > > Cc: [email protected] > > > > Subject: [Gen-art] Gen-art LC review of draft-ietf-pwe3-fc-encap > > > > > > > > I am the assigned Gen-ART reviewer for this draft. For background on > > > > Gen-ART, please see the FAQ at > > > > <http://wiki.tools.ietf.org/area/gen/trac/wiki/GenArtfaq>. > > > > > > > > Please resolve these comments along with any other Last Call comments > > > > you may receive. > > > > > > > > Document: draft-ietf-pwe3-fc-encap-14.txt > > > > Reviewer: Elwyn Davies > > > > Review Date: 16 February 2011 > > > > IETF LC End Date: 21 February 2011 > > > > IESG Telechat date: (if known) - > > > > > > > > Summary: This document still has some minor issues mainly relating to > > > > the (specification of the) usage of the Length and Payload Type fields > > > > in the PW Control Word. There are also some editorial items that need > > > > fixing. > > > > > > > > Major issues: > > > > None > > > > > > > > Minor issues: > > > > s3.1: The encoding of the PT values is not specified. Should an > > > > explicit error behaviour for control words with PT set to something > > > > other than 1,2, 4 or 6 be specified? > > > > > > > > s3.1: I note that RFC 3985 fails to specify the unit of the Length > > > > parameter (presumably bytes/octets, but since it seems to be used in > > > > various different ways it might be application specific) and does not > > > > specify the encoding for the parameter. This specification propagates > > > > this omission. > > > > > > > > s3.3: FC Frames: How is the Length field in the control word used here? > > > > Are there constraints on the Payload Type for this case? > > > > > > > > s3.3: Discussion of encoding of ordered sets: Is there an upper limit > > > > on the number of ordered sets in a single PW packet? This isn't made > > > > explicit but the size of the Length field which is supposed to be used > > > > for 'short packets' possibly restricts the number of ordered sets. If > > > > this is not the case how is the length specified if the total is more > > > > then 64 whatevers (see the comment above on s3.1). > > > > > > > > s3.3: Discussion of encoding of ordered sets: What payload types are > > > > allowed for this case? > > > > > > > > s3.3: Discussion of FC PW Control Frames: How is the Length field in the > > > > Control Word used in this case? If it isn't used, how is the size of > > > > the frame determined? > > > > > > > > Nits/editorial comments: > > > > Abstract/Section 1: For whatever reason the RFC Editor deems MPLS-TP to > > > > be a well-known abbreviation but not MPLS-TE.. so I guess MPLS-TE better > > > > be expanded. > > > > > > > > s1, next to last para: s/by comparison to/by comparison with (or in > > > > comparison to)/ > > > > > > > > s1.1, para 1: expand GFPT. > > > > > > > > s3: Is [FC-FS-2] a sufficient reference for the definition of 8b/10b > > > > encoding? I can't see the full text so I can't tell. There are lots of > > > > jargon items relating to 8b/10b later in s3. > > > > > > > > s3: This section contains a number of FC jargon terms. Some of them (in > > > > the first set of bullet points - FC-SW, FC-P2P, FC-AL) are not expanded > > > > at all. Others in the second set of bullets (FLOGI, PLOGI, ELP) are > > > > expanded on second appearance a little lower down. Towards the end > > > > 10GFC and 16GFC may also need expansion or a reference. > > > > > > > > s3, next to last para: (just checking!) Is Service class F right? Others > > > > are numbers. > > > > > > > > s3.3: Might be clearer if organized into three sub-sections for the > > > > three types of item transported. > > > > > > > > s3.3: A reference for the definitions of the FC Service Class 4 values > > > > mentioned (SOFi4, etc) is needed. > > > > > > > > s7, next to last para: RFC 3821 appears to prefer FCIP rather than FC/IP > > > > as an abbreviation. > > > > > > > > > > > > _______________________________________________ > > > > Gen-art mailing list > > > > [email protected] > > > > https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/gen-art > > > > > > _______________________________________________ Gen-art mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/gen-art
