Bernard, > I think the question is whether the Experiment will collect sufficient > data to determine whether > it would be useful to keep it going, and if so, what changes need to > be made. > > Currently, the document states that demonstration of interest is a > prerequisite, but little else. > However, interest by itself is probably not enough to allow > a SG to have a decent chance of > success. Figuring out when a SG can be profitably formed may turn out > to be an important > learning from the experiment, but the question is whether the current > proposal will provide > that information.
Yes. > Are we asking the IESG to identify which RFC 2418 criteria were not > met for WG formation? Ideally this should be the case already when decisions about BOF and WG acceptance are communicated. But I hope you are not asking to make this formal. Jari _______________________________________________ Gen-art mailing list [email protected] https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/gen-art
