Hi all, Here is my GENART review of Definitions of Managed Objects for FCIP. See footer for info about Gen-ART if you are confused.
This document is basically ready, except for 2 nits. Note that I am not a FC nor a MIB expert, so I am assuming the MIB doctors did their job & the WG did their job as well. 1) Please expand FCIP (and FC) in the title & abstract. Its hard to keep track of all of the acronyms in the IETF. 2) Subsections in Section 2 need a blank line between the subsection title & the text. I would imagine that there might be comments during IESG review, so I'd suggest the authors wait until there are additional IESG reviews before reving the document. thanks, John ============ Q: What is Gen-ART? A: The General Area Review Team. They provide gneralist reviews for the General Area director (currently Brian Carpenter), providing an additional set of eyes for documents as they are being considered for publication. Q: Who is Gen-ART? A: The current membership list is maintained at http://www.alvestrand.no/ietf/gen/art/reviewer-list.html. We do accept new reviewers - volunteers should contact the Gen-ART secretary (see below) < NOTE that this phrasing is Brian's, but the URL actually says "contact the General Area director" - we just need to say the same thing in both places> Q: What does the Gen-ART secretary do and how do I find him/her? A: The Gen-ART secretary is also listed on the membership page. The Gen-ART secretary tracks documents submitted for publication and assigns them to reviewers, and collects the reviews, posting them to http://www.alvestrand.no/ietf/gen/art/gen-art.html. Q: Why is my document being reviewed? A: Two possible answers - most Gen-ART reviews are now assigned at IETF Last Call time (answer #1). If a document is revised after IETF Last Call, or is processed so quickly that no Gen-ART reviewer has been assigned, it's reviewed after being placed on the IESG Telechat agenda (answer #2). Q: How was my Gen-ART reviewer selected? A: There is a mechanism, but it's more about leveling the review workload than selecting reviewers based on topic areas. Gen-ART reviewers are generalists, so we think this is OK. Q: Are the reviews public or private? A: The reviews are sent to the Gen-ART mailing list (which includes the General Area director). Ordinarily, copies are sent to shepherding ADs, document shepherds, working group chairs, and authors/editors, but the archives are publically viewable, at http://www.ietf.org/mail-archive/web/gen-art/current/index.html. Q: Are Gen-ART comments binding? A: Not unless the General Area director agrees with the comments. Gen-ART does not have a formal role in the standards approval process - we're simply providing input for the General Area director who is deciding how to ballot the document. If the General Area director agrees with a serious concern expressed in a Gen-ART review, the General Area director may ask the Gen-ART reviewer, "does the new version of the draft address your concerns?" Q: I have comments from a Gen-ART reviewer - do I revise the document immediately? A: Ask your AD/document shepherd. Practice varies between areas. A fair number of comments area resolved with Notes to the RFC Editor. But the General Area director will not ask for a respin before a telechat. Q: What if the Gen-ART reviewer is just flat wrong? A: The General Area director understands that these are reviews by generalists who are not experts in every protocol the IETF works on, plus security and MIBs. If you disagree with comments, say so. The ballot position is called "DISCUSS", not "IMPERIAL EDICT" or "BLACKMAIL". Q: Is there any written Gen-ART procedure? A: Currently http://www.ietf.org/internet-drafts/draft-doria-genart-experience-01.txt , and - guess what - we're still reviewing it :-) _______________________________________________ Gen-art mailing list [email protected] https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/gen-art
