This patch treats the GNAT-specific 'Img attribute as a callable entity which therefore can be renamed as a function. The prefix of the attribute reference is an object rather than a subtype, and it is not evaluated at the point of the renaming declaration.
Executing the following : gnatmake -q inst inst must yield: 12345 456 F2 = 456, Flag = TRUE F2 = 789, Flag = FALSE --- with Text_IO; use Text_IO; procedure Inst is generic with function F return String; procedure Gen; procedure Gen is begin Put_Line (F); end Gen; V : Integer; procedure Inst_Img is new Gen (V'Img); Table : array (Boolean) of Integer := (123, 456); Flag : Boolean := False; function F2 return String; function F2 return String renames Table(Flag)'Img; begin V := 12345; Inst_Img; Table (False) := 789; Flag := True; Put_Line (Table (Flag)'Img); Put_Line ("F2 = " & F2 & ", Flag = " & Boolean'Image (Flag)); Flag := False; Put_Line ("F2 = " & F2 & ", Flag = " & Boolean'Image (Flag)); end Inst; Tested on x86_64-pc-linux-gnu, committed on trunk 2013-07-08 Ed Schonberg <schonb...@adacore.com> * sem_ch8.adb (Attribute_Renaming): Treat 'Img as an attribute that can be renamed as a function.
Index: sem_ch8.adb =================================================================== --- sem_ch8.adb (revision 200757) +++ sem_ch8.adb (working copy) @@ -3318,12 +3318,14 @@ -- This procedure is called in the context of subprogram renaming, and -- thus the attribute must be one that is a subprogram. All of those - -- have at least one formal parameter, with the singular exception of - -- AST_Entry (which is a real oddity, it is odd that this can be renamed - -- at all!) + -- have at least one formal parameter, with the exceptions of AST_Entry + -- (which is a real oddity, it is odd that this can be renamed at all!) + -- and the GNAT attribute 'Img, which GNAT treats as renameable. if not Is_Non_Empty_List (Parameter_Specifications (Spec)) then - if Aname /= Name_AST_Entry then + if Aname /= Name_AST_Entry + and then Aname /= Name_Img + then Error_Msg_N ("subprogram renaming an attribute must have formals", N); return; @@ -3493,11 +3495,21 @@ and then Etype (Nam) /= RTE (RE_AST_Handler) then declare - P : constant Entity_Id := Prefix (Nam); + P : constant Node_Id := Prefix (Nam); begin - Find_Type (P); + -- The prefix of 'Img is an object that is evaluated for + -- each call of the function that renames it. + if Aname = Name_Img then + Preanalyze_And_Resolve (P); + + -- For all other attribute renamings, the prefix is a subtype. + + else + Find_Type (P); + end if; + if Is_Tagged_Type (Etype (P)) then Ensure_Freeze_Node (Etype (P)); Append_Freeze_Action (Etype (P), Body_Node);