On October 31, 2020 11:35:01 PM GMT+01:00, Jan Hubicka <hubi...@ucw.cz> wrote:
>> On 10/29/20 1:40 PM, Richard Biener wrote:
>> > On Thu, 29 Oct 2020, Jakub Jelinek wrote:
>> >
>> > > On Thu, Oct 29, 2020 at 05:00:40PM +0100, Jan Hubicka wrote:
>> > > > >
>> > > > > That's ugly and will for sure defeat warning / access code
>> > > > > when we access this as char[], no? I mean, we could
>> > > > > as well use 'int str[1];' here?
>> > > >
>> > > > Well, we always get char pointer via macro that is IMO OK, but
>I am also
>> > > > not very much in love with this.
>> > >
>> > > Do we treat signed char [...]; as typeless storage too, or just
>> > > what the C++ standard requires (i.e. char, unsigned char and
>std::byte
>> > > where the last one is enum type with unsigned char underlying
>type)?
>> >
>> > All that is covered by is_byte_access_type which includes all
>> > character types (including char16_t and wchar it seems) and
>std::byte.
>>
>> Well, that's a bug, apparently from the PR94923 patch (r11-499);
>previously
>> it was char, signed char, and unsigned char. And even that is too
>much;
>> even C++98 said just char and unsigned char could be used for
>bytewise
>> access.
>>
>> When C++17 clarified this with the notion of "provides storage", it
>applied
>> to only unsigned char and std::byte, not even the full set of
>byte-access
>> types. We still need to allow bytewise access using plain char, but
>perhaps
>> we don't need to treat plain char arrays as typeless.
>>
>> Attributes to say that a particular array does or does not provide
>storage
>> for objects of other types do sound useful.
>
>Thanks a lot for explanation!
>I am adding Martin Sebor to CC. Perhaps you can fix the problem with
>std::byte, and signed char to imply typeless storage and ideally also
>add an attribute? This seem too deep into C++ FE details for me.
>
>I was thiking a bit more about all accesses to trees getting same alias
>set. This is because we allow type puning through unions. If our tree
>datastructure was a C++ class hiearchy, this would not happen since
>accesses to specialized tree node would not be through unions but
>through casted pointers.
>
>We could do that with our acessor macros, too.
>I tried to turn (NODE)->base in our accesors to ((tree_base
>*)(node))->base
>and this breaks with const_tree pointers. However the following seem to
>work and get better TBAA.
>
>I think converting other acessors should be quite easy and make our
>predicates more easy to optimize.
>
>What do you think?
Can you adjust TREE_SET_CODE to assert the corresponding tree struct doesn't
change? Otherwise sure - this would be a good change. Can we avoid the online
function though? It'll make -O0 debugging even more awkward...
Richard.
>Honza
>
>diff --git a/gcc/tree.h b/gcc/tree.h
>index 7f0aa5b8d1d..cd8146808f7 100644
>--- a/gcc/tree.h
>+++ b/gcc/tree.h
>@@ -235,13 +235,24 @@ as_internal_fn (combined_fn code)
>
> #define NULL_TREE (tree) NULL
>
>+inline tree_base *
>+as_a_tree_base (tree t)
>+{
>+ return (tree_base *)t;
>+}
>+inline const tree_base *
>+as_a_tree_base (const_tree t)
>+{
>+ return (const tree_base *)t;
>+}
>+
> /* Define accessors for the fields that all tree nodes have
> (though some fields are not used for all kinds of nodes). */
>
> /* The tree-code says what kind of node it is.
> Codes are defined in tree.def. */
>-#define TREE_CODE(NODE) ((enum tree_code) (NODE)->base.code)
>-#define TREE_SET_CODE(NODE, VALUE) ((NODE)->base.code = (VALUE))
>+#define TREE_CODE(NODE) ((enum tree_code) (as_a_tree_base
>(NODE)->code))
>+#define TREE_SET_CODE(NODE, VALUE) (as_a_tree_base (NODE)->code =
>(VALUE))
>
> /* When checking is enabled, errors will be generated if a tree node
> is accessed incorrectly. The macros die with a fatal error. */
>@@ -642,7 +653,7 @@ extern void omp_clause_range_check_failed
>(const_tree, const char *, int,
> In IDENTIFIER_NODEs, this means that some extern decl for this name
> had its address taken. That matters for inline functions.
>In a STMT_EXPR, it means we want the result of the enclosed expression.
> */
>-#define TREE_ADDRESSABLE(NODE) ((NODE)->base.addressable_flag)
>+#define TREE_ADDRESSABLE(NODE) (as_a_tree_base
>(NODE)->addressable_flag)
>
>/* Set on a CALL_EXPR if the call is in a tail position, ie. just
>before the
>exit of a function. Calls for which this is true are candidates for
>tail
>@@ -670,7 +681,7 @@ extern void omp_clause_range_check_failed
>(const_tree, const char *, int,
> /* In a VAR_DECL, nonzero means allocate static storage.
> In a FUNCTION_DECL, nonzero if function has been defined.
> In a CONSTRUCTOR, nonzero means allocate static storage. */
>-#define TREE_STATIC(NODE) ((NODE)->base.static_flag)
>+#define TREE_STATIC(NODE) (as_a_tree_base (NODE)->static_flag)
>
> /* In an ADDR_EXPR, nonzero means do not use a trampoline. */
>#define TREE_NO_TRAMPOLINE(NODE) (ADDR_EXPR_CHECK
>(NODE)->base.static_flag)
>@@ -701,7 +712,7 @@ extern void omp_clause_range_check_failed
>(const_tree, const char *, int,
> warnings concerning the decl should be suppressed. This is used at
> least for used-before-set warnings, and it set after one warning is
> emitted. */
>-#define TREE_NO_WARNING(NODE) ((NODE)->base.nowarning_flag)
>+#define TREE_NO_WARNING(NODE) (as_a_tree_base (NODE)->nowarning_flag)
>
> /* Nonzero if we should warn about the change in empty class parameter
> passing ABI in this TU. */
>@@ -744,7 +755,7 @@ extern void omp_clause_range_check_failed
>(const_tree, const char *, int,
> In an IDENTIFIER_NODE, nonzero means an external declaration
> accessible from outside this translation unit was previously seen
> for this name in an inner scope. */
>-#define TREE_PUBLIC(NODE) ((NODE)->base.public_flag)
>+#define TREE_PUBLIC(NODE) (as_a_tree_base (NODE)->public_flag)
>
> /* In a _TYPE, indicates whether TYPE_CACHED_VALUES contains a vector
> of cached values, or is something else. */
>@@ -766,7 +777,7 @@ extern void omp_clause_range_check_failed
>(const_tree, const char *, int,
>reference to a volatile variable. In a ..._DECL, this is set only if
>the
>declaration said `volatile'. This will never be set for a constant.
>*/
> #define TREE_SIDE_EFFECTS(NODE) \
>- (NON_TYPE_CHECK (NODE)->base.side_effects_flag)
>+ (as_a_tree_base (NON_TYPE_CHECK (NODE))->side_effects_flag)
>
> /* In a LABEL_DECL, nonzero means this label had its address taken
> and therefore can never be deleted and is a jump target for
>@@ -796,7 +807,7 @@ extern void omp_clause_range_check_failed
>(const_tree, const char *, int,
> because eventually we may make that a different bit.
>
> If this bit is set in an expression, so is TREE_SIDE_EFFECTS. */
>-#define TREE_THIS_VOLATILE(NODE) ((NODE)->base.volatile_flag)
>+#define TREE_THIS_VOLATILE(NODE) (as_a_tree_base
>(NODE)->volatile_flag)
>
> /* Nonzero means this node will not trap. In an INDIRECT_REF, means
> accessing the memory pointed to won't generate a trap. However,
>@@ -877,20 +888,20 @@ extern void omp_clause_range_check_failed
>(const_tree, const char *, int,
>In a BLOCK node, nonzero if reorder_blocks has already seen this block.
> In an SSA_NAME node, nonzero if the SSA_NAME occurs in an abnormal
> PHI node. */
>-#define TREE_ASM_WRITTEN(NODE) ((NODE)->base.asm_written_flag)
>+#define TREE_ASM_WRITTEN(NODE) (as_a_tree_base
>(NODE)->asm_written_flag)
>
> /* Nonzero in a _DECL if the name is used in its scope.
> Nonzero in an expr node means inhibit warning if value is unused.
> In IDENTIFIER_NODEs, this means that some extern decl for this name
> was used.
>In a BLOCK, this means that the block contains variables that are used.
> */
>-#define TREE_USED(NODE) ((NODE)->base.used_flag)
>+#define TREE_USED(NODE) (as_a_tree_base (NODE)->used_flag)
>
> /* In a FUNCTION_DECL, nonzero means a call to the function cannot
> throw an exception. In a CALL_EXPR, nonzero means the call cannot
> throw. We can't easily check the node type here as the C++
> frontend also uses this flag (for AGGR_INIT_EXPR). */
>-#define TREE_NOTHROW(NODE) ((NODE)->base.nothrow_flag)
>+#define TREE_NOTHROW(NODE) (as_a_tree_base (NODE)->nothrow_flag)
>
> /* In a CALL_EXPR, means that it's safe to use the target of the call
> expansion as the return slot for a call that returns in memory. */
>@@ -939,9 +950,9 @@ extern void omp_clause_range_check_failed
>(const_tree, const char *, int,
> (CALL_EXPR_CHECK (NODE)->base.protected_flag)
>
> /* Used in classes in C++. */
>-#define TREE_PRIVATE(NODE) ((NODE)->base.private_flag)
>+#define TREE_PRIVATE(NODE) (as_a_tree_base (NODE)->private_flag)
> /* Used in classes in C++. */
>-#define TREE_PROTECTED(NODE) ((NODE)->base.protected_flag)
>+#define TREE_PROTECTED(NODE) (as_a_tree_base (NODE)->protected_flag)
>
> /* True if reference type NODE is a C++ rvalue reference. */
> #define TYPE_REF_IS_RVALUE(NODE) \
>@@ -950,7 +961,7 @@ extern void omp_clause_range_check_failed
>(const_tree, const char *, int,
> /* Nonzero in a _DECL if the use of the name is defined as a
> deprecated feature by __attribute__((deprecated)). */
> #define TREE_DEPRECATED(NODE) \
>- ((NODE)->base.deprecated_flag)
>+ (as_a_tree_base (NODE)->deprecated_flag)
>
> /* Nonzero indicates an IDENTIFIER_NODE that names an anonymous
> aggregate, (as created by anon_aggr_name_format). */
>@@ -2170,7 +2181,7 @@ extern tree vector_element_bits_tree
>(const_tree);
>
>/* Used to keep track of visited nodes in tree traversals. This is set
>to
> 0 by copy_node and make_node. */
>-#define TREE_VISITED(NODE) ((NODE)->base.visited)
>+#define TREE_VISITED(NODE) (as_a_tree_base (NODE)->visited)
>
> /* If set in an ARRAY_TYPE, indicates a string type (for languages
> that distinguish string from array of char).
