http://gcc.gnu.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=58016

--- Comment #4 from joseph at codesourcery dot com <joseph at codesourcery dot 
com> ---
__STDC_VERSION__ describes *intent* of command-line options (as regards 
differences between standard versions, to the extent that those are 
implemented).  This is the same principle that has been documented for 
__STDC__ since at least GCC 2.0.

  "Sometimes people say that defining @code{__STDC__} in a compiler that
  does not completely conform to the ANSI C standard somehow violates the
  standard.  This is illogical.  The standard is a standard for compilers
  that are supposed to conform.  It says nothing about what any other
  compilers should do.  Whatever the ANSI C standard says is relevant to
  the design of plain @samp{gcc} without @samp{-ansi} only for pragmatic
  reasons, not as a requirement."

(quoted from the GCC 2.0 manual).

As a pragmatic matter, it's useful for users of standards modes that are 
incomplete to be able to tell which of those modes is in use, and 
__STDC_VERSION__ is the natural macro to define to distinguish between 
them.  gcc -std=c11 is a compiler explicitly claimed not to conform.

Reply via email to