Michael Van Canneyt wrote: > MPI is for passing messages between parallel running tasks. (the name > means Message Passing Interface) > This is what Active Objects does. > > To me, the difference seems that Active Objects runs within a single > process, and MPI allows to run the tasks in different processes, even > on different machines. That is correct. The active objects can run multple tasks with a choosen number of threads, all within the same process. By default, each active object has its own associated thread.
MPI on the other hand can send messages accross multiple machines and processes. This requires either a shared memory or a serialization layer, neither of which I looked into. Historically, the main reason I wrote this was because the thread management in BpmDj (http://bpmdj.yellowcouch.org/) had become a nightmare and the only sensible way to deal with this was thinking in terms of message queues. Implementing that however was remarkably hard. Especially the fairness requirement was hard to solve. E.g: 1000 tasks sending messages to 1 task should not keep that one task from performing work. > It seems to me that there are more parallels between MPI and Active > Objects > than you think. Both are tools for parallel (sic) computing, after all. Well, I would say: give it a try. If somebody feels it would be useful to extend it accross process by adding an extra new class that would serialize a message before sending it to a target, that would be interesting. However, in that case, we must think about passing a local stub through a message to a remote active object. That would require the serializer to deseriealize this 'local stub' to either the local active object or to a new stub that connects to the originally intended remote active object. So, this will heavily depend on the serialisation and deserialisation capabilities of fpc. And of course, I have no experience with that as such. Wkr, -- http://werner.yellowcouch.org/
signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature
_______________________________________________ fpc-pascal maillist - fpc-pascal@lists.freepascal.org http://lists.freepascal.org/mailman/listinfo/fpc-pascal
