On Monday 21 January 2008 13:01, Graeme Geldenhuys wrote:
> On 21/01/2008, Vinzent Hoefler <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> > As an example where most tools just put out nonsense, consider this:
> > |type
> > | CPU_Ins = (Add, Sub, Mul, Div,
> > | Jnz, Jz, Jnc, Jc,
> > | Call, Ret,
> > | Push, Pop,
> > | ...);
>
> This is so easy to accomplish with 'elastic tabstops' (ET).
No, it ain't.
> ET is
> all about keeping alignment of text in columns. Trailing comments,
> column in code like you shown above etc..Just watch the flash demo of
> ET or try the Java example (though a bit dated I believe).
I tried the Java example and the first thing which struck me was this:
|int someDemoCode( int fred,
| int wilma)
^^
To accomplish it's task of detecting tabular design, it inserts tabstops
where no tabstops belong.
Tests:
1) If I remove the tab before "int fred", the "int wilma" is not even
aligned anymore. Even worse.
2) If I put the tabstop "typographically correct" as it should be (that
means: right before the parentheses)[1], it aligns "int wilma", but of
course right after the tab stop, so it doesn't start below "int fred",
but right below the parentheses. Wrong, again.
And that's what the Eclipse auto-formatter already did for years and the
reason why we disabled it.
We simply came to the conclusion, that if we manually format with spaces
we'll be typing faster, because we wouldn't have to fight the "tool"
anymore.
Further, all this even bites with the "it only saves spaces". If it does
in the end, then there's no way to detect where the tabs were supposed
to be.
So, as I've mentioned already, that's another tool that fails the task.
Not to mention, that I initially talked about automated tools, not
mere "editor-plugins", that even seem to even fail on the first try to
reload a saved file and display it the same as before I saved it.
Vinzent.
[1] In normal text( you don't write parentheses like that ), do you?
_______________________________________________
fpc-pascal maillist - fpc-pascal@lists.freepascal.org
http://lists.freepascal.org/mailman/listinfo/fpc-pascal
