On Fri, Mar 25, 2011 at 11:33, Strainu <strain...@gmail.com> wrote: > I personally enjoy the independence that each project has in the > Wikimedia universe. Therefore, I've given much thought on wether I > should write this email. Bun in the situation I will present below, I > really don't know what more can be done according to the current > policies in effect on my home wiki (ro.wikipedia). I ask your help in > finding a path to follow. > > One of our users has created a page for tracking "mistakes" made by > other users [1], which propted protests from other users, including > myself [2]. Eventually, I asked for the deletion of the page at the > Romanian equivalent of [[WP:AFD]] on 20th of February [3]. The rules > for deleting the pages are very much the same as on en.wp (see > [[:en:WP:NotEarly]]), however the user page rules are not quite the > same as on en.wp. There is an ongoing debate on ro.wp on using en.wp > rules when missing an equivalent policy. this was used by the user who > created the page in his defense. > > On ro.wp it sometimes happens that decisions on deleting pages take > much longer than a week, so I would expect a decision to be made > sometime soon. However, this request is special because all the active > sysops are either present in the page in question or were involved in > the discussions about it, so it would be unfair of them to close it. > > What do you think the following steps should be? Should we call some > of the other sysops from "retirement"? Should we appeal to someone > from the arbcom on en.wp?
No steward has a problem to act if there is community consensus. However, at the RfD page which you provided [1] I see two "delete" positions (including yourself as a nominator) and two "keep" positions, which can't be named as a "community consensus". [1] http://ro.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Pagini_de_%C8%99ters#Utilizator:Turbojet.2FGre.C8.99eli _______________________________________________ foundation-l mailing list foundation-l@lists.wikimedia.org Unsubscribe: https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/foundation-l
