-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA512 On 08/15/2014 11:23 AM, Thomas Goirand wrote:
> On 08/15/2014 08:20 PM, Michael Niedermayer wrote: >>> Absolutely everyone should *always* be able to leave comments, be >>> it positive or negative. >> >> yes, i fully agree and this also was always so in FFmpeg. In that >> sense everyone is welcome to subscribe to ffmpeg-devel and review >> and comment patches. That of course includes Libav developers and >> everyone else. And more reviewers would also certainly help, so >> yeah anyone reading this and wanting to help review patches, you >> are welcome! > > Well, using a mailing list to review patches is something we were > doing 10 years ago. It's also something the Linux kernel is still doing, with apparent success. I for one consider it to be a much more public, transparent, and discoverable way to let proposed patches and the review of same be open to public view, compared to the way various other projects seem to do it. Making sure everything passes through the mailing list, and most if not all substantive discussion happens on the mailing list, is a lot better than having some discussion on the mailing lists and some on a bug tracker and some on IRC and some via private mail and so on. (The most ridiculously extreme example of this fragmentation that I know of is probably the Mozilla project.) There's nothing wrong with having discussion in those various areas, of course; it's probably inevitable, and it's even a good thing. It's just that it's a lot harder for someone not intimately involved with the project to follow discussion if it happens in such a variety of places, and there's value to be found in making sure that everything passes through one central (discussion-enabled) point before landing. - -- The Wanderer Secrecy is the beginning of tyranny. A government exists to serve its citizens, not to control them. -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG v1 Comment: Using GnuPG with Mozilla - http://enigmail.mozdev.org/ iQIcBAEBCgAGBQJT7izqAAoJEASpNY00KDJr8PwP+gNPrmz3G1SDFBP0WPW7WEn/ BBFAFkWXEkezThYnjqYfHxUjwHBZOOpLfykfhlx7uV5O+nqy5BDDMHLzBxVEvaKp 5On9SaRB6/DYzAf9HvSJm+teHqRtNP0xKrcjRI+AgQ9n3Meax3OWi7jiNSIijAlX srvhfjqgRAdNIB+dAnv8uhWhsAbN0njAPqegolFunAG8ZlWA4kcA5zt5uVaQrWPZ y8LqZ/bB7xYbqTAO+kENhNoMzItqANUKZNhJKW/Fk6Dln/kIKWYE5Uiiil2BOHc7 KNyPxvrfjAj/LYdazgknu2tcAlgHbPBbbjjqYFivkc2sG+9s1t5QkEdkdJw7w3v8 OQpUwwF3gRGHebp1ODtyCuVC8jsmtBAwM+s0H5aqF0Tp6NyjgYFxtYrfHvvnvXmX 1lew8VW6WogIlJ1wDXCS8057gR877wMa8r61d6XbdHXcnARxoFYI1ngUUsKYjXyU YJkRgxTZTtUZ9QNfex8sdja1PiIw96m4XLeW1uTozRR0EcQRBarphBCscQhmp0Sm pdopwrFYMnZtNOE2nEqbwQtkNm1AXmABG18GbhcPX7LqEXsys6Odn8o1zqJYpx2h 7aQzpXbhjHUwihelR5yV6dASRt1LBD3icCR0uoWaAb80b0Li9cdV07FLon20XExS mwURtzhiqxowV931+Bvh =Jxa+ -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- _______________________________________________ ffmpeg-devel mailing list ffmpeg-devel@ffmpeg.org http://ffmpeg.org/mailman/listinfo/ffmpeg-devel
