I agree that transient dispatchers would be great and consistent. What is not so great with transient currently is it’s lacking support for lisp-variable/option workflows. Transient is good for command-line arguments, but setting options for emacs functions is not as streamlined (this would be relevant for the export dispatcher for example).
Some new classes for these types of options would probably need to be defined, since the default infix-classes assume all options are strings. I recently did try to implement a transient dispatcher this for my orgqda package: https://gitlab.com/andersjohansson/orgqda/-/blob/main/orgqda-transient.el Partly inspired by org-ql: https://github.com/alphapapa/org-ql/blob/048de35b07d8d29fc6fa49c34d7ba1fd1c912011/org-ql-view.el#L501 I now store the options as plists in buffer-local-variables, which I am not sure is optimal and perhaps goes against the idea of saving options with transient. So still some work to do there. By the way. Getting started with transient is way easier with this tutorial than with the rather abstract info pages: https://github.com/magit/transient/wiki/Developer-Quick-Start-Guide Best, Anders Johansson
