Stig Brautaset writes:
> I'm seeing some weirdness with tags-todo vs tags custom agenda commands.
> Below is the smallest case I've managed to narrow it down to. I would
> *expect* that all the a1-4 commands return the same results, and that
> the b1-4 return the same results. That is not what I'm seeing, however.
>
> (setq-default org-agenda-custom-commands
> '(("a1" "A1" tags-todo "-PROJ/TODO")
> ("a2" "A2" tags "-PROJ/TODO")
> ("a3" "A3" ((tags-todo "-PROJ/TODO")))
> ("a4" "A4" ((tags "-PROJ/TODO")))
>
> ("b1" "B1" tags-todo "-PROJ/DONE")
> ("b2" "B2" tags "-PROJ/DONE")
> ("b3" "B3" ((tags-todo "-PROJ/DONE")))
> ("b4" "B4" ((tags "-PROJ/DONE")))))
>
I agree with your expectation that a1-4 should be the same. Why do you
expect that b1-4 would be? Shouldn't tags-todo consider only none-DONE
todo items, in the same spirit as m versus M? In other words, I'd
expect b1 and b3 to be empty by definition.
> The effect of a1 & a2 appears identical to eachother, and a3 & a4 too,
> but a1-2 and a3-4 differ (in that the former seems to include scheduled
> items, but the latter does not.)
It's helpful if you provide a minimal test file. I've tried to come up
with one that I think should capture what you're describing.
--8<---------------cut here---------------start------------->8---
* TODO h1 :PROJ:
* TODO h2
* DONE h3 :PROJ:
* DONE h4
* TODO h5 :PROJ:
SCHEDULED: <2020-06-14 Sun>
* TODO h6
SCHEDULED: <2020-06-14 Sun>
* DONE h7 :PROJ:
SCHEDULED: <2020-06-14 Sun>
* DONE h8
SCHEDULED: <2020-06-14 Sun>
--8<---------------cut here---------------end--------------->8---
With that, a1-4 all show:
scratch: TODO h2
scratch: TODO h6
That doesn't match what you're seeing. I'm testing with 706970 checked
out, the commit you reported in your follow-up message.
> What I'm seeing for b1-4 is even weirder. Here I observe b1, b2 and b4
> have identical behaviour[*], but b3 is the odd one out: while the other
> three return a list of DONE non-project tasks, b3 doesn't find anything.
>
> [*] I suspect the reason b2 and b4 are identical is that I have no
> scheduled DONE tasks.
For b2 and b4, I see
scratch: DONE h4
scratch: DONE h8
b1 and b3 are empty, which I think is expected given the tags-todo type.
