Moin! On 21 Feb 2023, at 6:32, Viktor Dukhovni wrote: > This leaves 6,466 cases to examine more closely: > > 1. 3,773 are in complete agreement with the authoritative A/AAAA > records. > > 2. 1,447 have authoritative A/AAAA records completely distinct > from the sibling glue. > > 3. 1,414 return NXDOMAIN from the auth zone! > > 4. 74 return NODATA from the auth zone for both A and AAAA! > > 5. 213 return SERFAIL from the auth zone A and AAAA lookups. > > Of the above, case "1" could perhaps reduce latency, but is otherwise > redundant (modulo exceedingly rare cyclic depedendencies).
These “rare” cases where the domain is not resolvable when a glue is not present are the ones this draft is done for. So did you look how rare they were in your dataset? Being able to resolve instead of not resolving IMHO has value even if the number is not big. We all know that a lot of data in the DNS is garbage, that should not stop us from using the good data. So long -Ralf ——- Ralf Weber _______________________________________________ DNSOP mailing list DNSOP@ietf.org https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/dnsop
