Dne 26. 10. 22 v 19:02 Klaus Frank napsal(a):
I don't quite understand what the controversial part with this is, but
why not just copy RFC7686 (onion special use domain name) for .ALT?
Please don't.
RFC7686 requires that all DNS software, both recursive and
authoritative, treats .onion in specific way. AFAIK this is ignored by
many. A standard that is widely being deliberately ignored is not a best
standard.
Moreover, it requires that non-root authoritative servers answer
NXDOMAIN out of their bailiwicks, which is against all other standards
and general DNS concepts.
I suspect that RFC7686 had not been reviewed enough by DNS nerds before
published. Dunno the history, but please at least, don't repeat it.
Thanks,
Libor
_______________________________________________
DNSOP mailing list
DNSOP@ietf.org
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/dnsop
