> Hi :-) > > John Bambenek <j...@bambenekconsulting.com> wrote: > >> That said, I agree it cannot solve GDPR or other policy concerns. > > > Why? GDPR applies to IP addresses, that doesn't impact DNS yet. > > You appear to have confused IP with P(I)I: personally identifying > information. > > All whois data is PII, in the case where people register > individual details, as opposed to organizational roles. I think > you may need to do a bit more research on this topic, you seem to > have misunderstood a thing or two.
One, IP addresses in some cases are PII (see here: https://eugdprcompliant.com/personal-data/). Two, in some cases whois data is NOT PII (i.e. role based accounts, which are allowed here). You could set contact info to "Mail Administrator" and "ab...@domain.com" and that's fine here. > > > I'm genuinely curious of something. The most I've engaged in > > this debate about WHOIS records and what is or is useful in > > fighting abuse, the opinions of those who actually fight abuse > > for a living are discarded a priori. > > I also have done this for a living. I expect everyone on this > list has, to a certain degree. > > I guess what I'm saying is, I probably wouldn't buy what you're > selling. > > Further, I agree with others that it's not our job to standardize > and encourage the kind of large scale self-doxxing such products > would undeniably benefit from. That would be to throw the > average-Joe under the bus, for the benefit of the minority who > decide to invest in such tools (whether they are actually > effective or not). If you put personal information, that's your choice. If you put role-based info, that's your choice. Same as what you post on twitter, facebook, or whatever. This enables the choice to "self-dox" (something I think is an odd formulation. > So this is me changing my mind, I don't think potential > automation use-cases justify this. > > Cheers, > - Bjarni > _______________________________________________ DNSOP mailing list DNSOP@ietf.org https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/dnsop