On 16Jul15, Dave Lawrence allegedly wrote: > > I would think that if we're to proceed with this protocol then the > > white list requirement should be removed from the spec. > > I don't see language in the current draft that makes a whitelist a > requirement. The language I do see doesn't even use 2119 > capitalization, so it's even softer than usual. If there is a > statement in there that you think mandates whitelists
True, there is no mandate, but all implementations that I'm aware of, have implemented a white list. While the language is softer in -02, is it necessary at all as it will only continue to encourage white list behavior just as the previous language did. IOWs, why not remove 11.2 completely? Mark. _______________________________________________ DNSOP mailing list DNSOP@ietf.org https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/dnsop
