Comments? DNSOP WG Minutes IETF 71 @ Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, US March 11, 2008
1. WG Administration notes RFC 5138 "6to4 Reverse DNS" published Draft "reflectors are evil" faces two DISCUSSes in IESG Draft "default local zones" is in or past WG last call 2. Charter Revision Proposal @Mic comments: On mention of benchmarking Stephane B: isn't benchmarking the domain of another WG? Ralph Bonica: (Area Director) says, talk with Al [NM]orton of BMWG On omission of specific DNS systems General comment: group never had oversight role on any system, mentions in the previous charter were for illustration Andrew Sullivan: Proposed charter never mentions "operation of DNS." Hum on adding something on "operation of DNS" - some support Milestones - need updating 3. Discussions of active drafts Promises to review: Reverse Map Considerations: Olafur, Jaap, Liman, Olaf, Jinmei AS112-ops and -attack: Andrew Sullivan, Brian Dickson, Jaap, Stephane B, Mark A Response Size: Matt Larson, David Blacka, Brian D, Olafur, Eric Nelson DNSSEC trust anchor: Scott Rose, Olaf, John Dickinson, Sam, Matt (the guy who won the hockey tickets), Joe G, David Blacka, Russ Mundy Resolver priming - currently expired General comment (which was unclear to me the minute taker) Brian Dickson: General operations of resolvers, is there any need for meta- priming, bootstrap for DNS resolver configuration, should WG have default config's for implementers? Akira Kato - latest version of Response Size is -10 Stephane B - version -10 is okay About 5 have read the -10 version 5 documents to go to staggered last calls Other Drafts Key Rollover State Terminology - Olafur G and Johan Ihren -00 individual submission draft-gudmundsson-life-of-dnskey-00.txt Unification of terminology needed generated->published->used/active->retired->removed (and revoked) 8 or 9 state definitions headed for informational track John Dickinson: what about signature state terms? Answer: no, what do you want? Sam Weiler: is this a partial rewrite of the spec? Chair: ? Terms are not precise enough (now). Sam: Not sure this document is a good starting point. Hum: adopt/use doc loud, do not use doc, low, use something else - silence (Scribe's Note: I cannot detect silence too well, bad hearing and all) Design team current topic: Nameserver Control Protocol (presenter Jaap) 4 IETF's ago - protocol for this going nowhere 2 IETF's ago - design team wish list little happening now - unfinished, rough document What to do - design team. Ideas but no commitment. Other WGs DNSEXT - Cookies proposal (message authentication) v6ops - NAT PT ENUM - EDNS 0 NAT-PT - rewrite DNS packets on the fly Kurtis Lindquist: v6ops co-chair, new translation thru NAT-PT Kim from Apple: DNS-ALG is not wanted Kurtis Lindquist: requirements gathering is currently on-going Ed Lewis: does this include "totd"? Answer: yes Mark A: detailed commentary about DNSSEC and totd ENUM - EDNS0 Olafur Gudmundsson: DNSEXT is revising EDNS0 definition now Alex Mayerhofer - ENUM working group ENUM services guide, new version. Covers service registration. Needs words on DNS. Other WGs Brian Dickson - Routing Research Group generating new RR types Stephane B - 2nd Meeting on Friday morning, DNS-based mapping -- -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Edward Lewis +1-571-434-5468 NeuStar Never confuse activity with progress. Activity pays more. _______________________________________________ DNSOP mailing list DNSOP@ietf.org https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/dnsop
