On 20-Dec-2006, at 11:59, David Conrad wrote:
Stephane,
I would like to know if people here believe that this work is on-
topic
for the WG. It does not change the protocol (so it does not seem
adapted to DNS Extensions) but it is not really "DNS operations".
It sounds to me like you're wanting to define a new protocol. I
think the topic broad enough that it would justify spinning up a
BOF and a new working group. But that's probably just me.
Well, I haven't read through the requirements document yet, but there
are approaches which meet the general goals that I think it's talking
about which don't involve a new protocol.
Consider the various approaches used by ISC and others to populate a
zone with data that can be extracted by a nameserver and used to
configure itself, for example. No protocol there -- more like a zone
schema.
Joe
_______________________________________________
DNSOP mailing list
DNSOP@ietf.org
https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/dnsop
