Just in case anyone's keeping track, we've spoken to Isilon, BlueArc and 
Exanet.  We're already familiar with NetApp and EMC.

It's interesting stuff, and from an R&D HPC perspective, the newer kids on 
the block are compelling.

However, from a corporate enterprise NAS perspective, it's looking more 
and more like the big boys (NetApp and EMC) are the clear winners.

While the performance game may go to the other three, I was surprised to 
see a slide from Exanet that put NetApp second in terms of performance 
(note: not *price/performance* :) ).

The enterprise features just aren't there for the new guys.  We're asking 
about things like:
snapshot cloning/writable snaps
WORM/compliance locking
integration with tools like Oracle backups, Exchange, and VMWare VCB

Even global support seems to be a bit of a challenge, depending on how 
global we're talking.

We're still hashing things out.  Thankfully, the company is more than 
willing to deal with multiple vendors to ensure that the project is 
matched to the appropriate storage vendor.  Our biggest problem with 
NetApp, besides the expense, is the lack of scalability and global 
namespace, which is a real shame.

-Adam

_______________________________________________
Discuss mailing list
Discuss@lopsa.org
http://lopsa.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/discuss
This list provided by the League of Professional System Administrators
 http://lopsa.org/

Reply via email to