GitHub user zyratlo added a comment to the discussion: Where should the helper 
functions go in an exported Python script?

Here are the options I can think of for Copy:

1. **Keep copy, and it gives the script without the helpers.**
Copy gives the same script as in the ZIP, so it won't run on its own. This 
works for the case you mentioned where someone already has `texera_helpers.py`, 
but for anyone exporting for the first time, copy is a dead end. They'd have to 
download the ZIP anyway, so they might as well have downloaded in the first 
place.

2. **Keep copy, and include the helpers so it runs out of the box.**
This could use the `main()` layout from my earlier comment, or something else. 
The user can run a copied script right away, but the format is different from 
the download.

3. **Remove copy and only allow download.**
This avoids both problems (different formats, or a copied script that doesn't 
run), but users can no longer paste the script straight into a notebook or an 
existing file.

I personally support 2. I think it's fine for copy and download to give 
different formats, since they're for different uses, but I would like to hear 
what other people think too.

GitHub link: 
https://github.com/apache/texera/discussions/9368#discussioncomment-19504730

----
This is an automatically sent email for [email protected].
To unsubscribe, please send an email to: [email protected]

Reply via email to