The problem is that plugins are not equivalent. There is AFAIK no equivalent to the maven shader plugin for SBT. There is an SBT plugin which can apparently read POM XML files (sbt-pom-reader). However, it can't possibly handle plugins, which is still problematic.
On Tue, Feb 25, 2014 at 3:31 PM, yao <yaosheng...@gmail.com> wrote: > I would prefer keep both of them, it would be better even if that means > pom.xml will be generated using sbt. Some company, like my current one, > have their own build infrastructures built on top of maven. It is not easy > to support sbt for these potential spark clients. But I do agree to only > keep one if there is a promising way to generate correct configuration from > the other. > > -Shengzhe > > > On Tue, Feb 25, 2014 at 3:20 PM, Evan Chan <e...@ooyala.com> wrote: > >> The correct way to exclude dependencies in SBT is actually to declare >> a dependency as "provided". I'm not familiar with Maven or its >> dependencySet, but provided will mark the entire dependency tree as >> excluded. It is also possible to exclude jar by jar, but this is >> pretty error prone and messy. >> >> On Tue, Feb 25, 2014 at 2:45 PM, Koert Kuipers <ko...@tresata.com> wrote: >> > yes in sbt assembly you can exclude jars (although i never had a need for >> > this) and files in jars. >> > >> > for example i frequently remove log4j.properties, because for whatever >> > reason hadoop decided to include it making it very difficult to use our >> own >> > logging config. >> > >> > >> > >> > On Tue, Feb 25, 2014 at 4:24 PM, Konstantin Boudnik <c...@apache.org> >> wrote: >> > >> >> On Fri, Feb 21, 2014 at 11:11AM, Patrick Wendell wrote: >> >> > Kos - thanks for chiming in. Could you be more specific about what is >> >> > available in maven and not in sbt for these issues? I took a look at >> >> > the bigtop code relating to Spark. As far as I could tell [1] was the >> >> > main point of integration with the build system (maybe there are other >> >> > integration points)? >> >> > >> >> > > - in order to integrate Spark well into existing Hadoop stack it >> was >> >> > > necessary to have a way to avoid transitive dependencies >> >> duplications and >> >> > > possible conflicts. >> >> > > >> >> > > E.g. Maven assembly allows us to avoid adding _all_ Hadoop libs >> >> and later >> >> > > merely declare Spark package dependency on standard Bigtop >> Hadoop >> >> > > packages. And yes - Bigtop packaging means the naming and layout >> >> would be >> >> > > standard across all commercial Hadoop distributions that are >> worth >> >> > > mentioning: ASF Bigtop convenience binary packages, and >> Cloudera or >> >> > > Hortonworks packages. Hence, the downstream user doesn't need to >> >> spend any >> >> > > effort to make sure that Spark "clicks-in" properly. >> >> > >> >> > The sbt build also allows you to plug in a Hadoop version similar to >> >> > the maven build. >> >> >> >> I am actually talking about an ability to exclude a set of dependencies >> >> from an >> >> assembly, similarly to what's happening in dependencySet sections of >> >> assembly/src/main/assembly/assembly.xml >> >> If there is a comparable functionality in Sbt, that would help quite a >> bit, >> >> apparently. >> >> >> >> Cos >> >> >> >> > > - Maven provides a relatively easy way to deal with the jar-hell >> >> problem, >> >> > > although the original maven build was just Shader'ing everything >> >> into a >> >> > > huge lump of class files. Oftentimes ending up with classes >> >> slamming on >> >> > > top of each other from different transitive dependencies. >> >> > >> >> > AFIAK we are only using the shade plug-in to deal with conflict >> >> > resolution in the assembly jar. These are dealt with in sbt via the >> >> > sbt assembly plug-in in an identical way. Is there a difference? >> >> >> >> I am bringing up the Sharder, because it is an awful hack, which is >> can't >> >> be >> >> used in real controlled deployment. >> >> >> >> Cos >> >> >> >> > [1] >> >> >> https://git-wip-us.apache.org/repos/asf?p=bigtop.git;a=blob;f=bigtop-packages/src/common/spark/do-component-build;h=428540e0f6aa56cd7e78eb1c831aa7fe9496a08f;hb=master >> >> >> >> >> >> -- >> -- >> Evan Chan >> Staff Engineer >> e...@ooyala.com | >> -- -- Evan Chan Staff Engineer e...@ooyala.com |
