On Tue, Mar 31, 2015 at 06:17:42PM +0000, Field, Brian wrote:
> I?m L2 challenged, so please forgive my lack of clue in this space.

Me too ;-)

> First, is CDP really a BPDU?  It?s not performing any sort of spanning
> tree functionality so I question why OVS?s forwarding of CDP frames is
> tied to the bpdu-forwarding value.   Is there a reason why CDP is included
> in the list protocols tied to bpdu-forwarding?

Thanks for the question.

CDP is not a BPDU.  The option when originally proposed applied only
to STP BPDUs and other IEEE reserved protocols, but it was generalized
later to other protocols that should not be forwarded across switches.

I changed the introduction to: "Controls forwarding of BPDUs and other
network control frames when NORMAL action is invoked." to clarify.

> Is the following correct:
> 
> If STP is enabled, then the setting for bpdu-forwarding has no effect.  If
> STP is not enabled, then setting bpdu-forwarding to true causes OVS to
> forward BPDUs.

To be entirely pedantic:

    If STP is enabled, then the setting for bpdu-forwarding has no effect
    on STP BPDUs.  If STP is not enabled, then setting bpdu-forwarding to
    true causes OVS to forward BPDUs and other network control frames.

Thanks a lot for the questions!  I'm happy that we managed to improve
the documentation here.
_______________________________________________
dev mailing list
dev@openvswitch.org
http://openvswitch.org/mailman/listinfo/dev

Reply via email to