I understand that there have been exceptions made for Apache projects to
allow GPL support tools into Apache project.  I would not have any
difficulty granting those repositories to the project.  But I cannot
comfortably use the github NuttX repository.

The GPL projects no longer exist.  I keep snapshots because they are necessary to NuttX and are not generally available elsewhere (without a bit of Googling):  e.g. kcoinfig-frontends.  I also have some snapshots of old GPL tools that runs with NuttX; newer versions probably do not:  Eg., genromfs.  There are other necessary tarballs there just to support on-stop-shopping:  E.g., gperf

There are also custom implementations for NuttX that leverage GPL code but for which there is no upstream project like the NuttX host nxfuse implementation.

And all of the buildtest files are there.

No, there is nothing that can be moved upstream.

There are also binaries for loading into WiFi chips there.  You cannot use the WiFi chips with the firmware binaries.  There are not GPL and can be free distributed.  But they are not BSD or Apache either.

Everything is critical for building NuttX and supporting NuttX configurations and testing.  Nothing can be in an open repository.  Nothing can go upstream.  Nothing can go to the Apache repositories (without some special dispensation).



Reply via email to