[
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/LUCENE-8245?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:comment-tabpanel&focusedCommentId=16430427#comment-16430427
]
Karl Wright commented on LUCENE-8245:
-------------------------------------
Ok, looking at the crossings we get, here's the complete output:
{code}
[junit4] 1>
[junit4] 1> Considering edge [lat=-1.4506713533447755,
lon=-1.2251247551355924([X=0.04060395941016342, Y=-0.11274773940940182,
Z=-0.9927936672533157])] -> [lat=4.9E-324, lon=0.0([X=1.0, Y=0.0, Z=4.9E-324])]
[junit4] 1> start point travel dist=-0.11274773940907501; end point
travel dist=3.268072236836579E-13
[junit4] 1> start point travel above dist=-0.11274773940806501; end point
travel above dist=1.336807223683658E-12
[junit4] 1> start point travel below dist=-0.11274773941008501; end point
travel below dist=-6.831927763163422E-13
[junit4] 1> start point testpoint dist=-0.34019438500826027; end point
testpoint dist=0.6525992822450555
[junit4] 1> start point testpoint above dist=-0.3401943850072502; end
point testpoint above dist=0.6525992822460656
[junit4] 1> start point testpoint below dist=-0.34019438500927035; end
point testpoint below dist=0.6525992822440454
[junit4] 1> Travel inner point [X=1.0, Y=-1.336807223683658E-12,
Z=-1.1771178322187736E-11]; edgeplane=0.0; travelInsidePlane=0.0
[junit4] 1> Test point inner point [X=0.7540698997149413,
Y=-0.07411317803504912, Z=-0.6525992822440454]; edgeplane=0.0;
testPointInsidePlane=0.0
[junit4] 1> Edge added 2 to innerCrossingCount
[junit4] 1> Test point outer point [X=0.7540698997131706,
Y=-0.07411317803527853, Z=-0.6525992822460656]; edgeplane=0.0;
testPointOutsidePlane=0.0
[junit4] 1> Edge added 1 to outerCrossingCount
[junit4] 1>
[junit4] 1> Considering edge [lat=4.9E-324, lon=0.0([X=1.0, Y=0.0,
Z=4.9E-324])] -> [lat=0.13953211802880663,
lon=-2.443438340098597([X=-0.7585849990851791, Y=-0.6365576248361361,
Z=0.139079795174987])]
[junit4] 1> start point travel dist=3.268072236836579E-13; end point
travel dist=-0.6365576248358092
[junit4] 1> start point travel above dist=1.336807223683658E-12; end
point travel above dist=-0.6365576248347993
[junit4] 1> start point travel below dist=-6.831927763163422E-13; end
point travel below dist=-0.6365576248368193
[junit4] 1> start point testpoint dist=0.6525992822450555; end point
testpoint dist=0.7916790774200425
[junit4] 1> start point testpoint above dist=0.6525992822460656; end
point testpoint above dist=0.7916790774210526
[junit4] 1> start point testpoint below dist=0.6525992822440454; end
point testpoint below dist=0.7916790774190324
[junit4] 1> Travel inner point [X=1.0, Y=-1.3368072236836578E-12,
Z=2.920754816285907E-13]; edgeplane=-5.0487097934144756E-29;
travelInsidePlane=2.0194839173657902E-28
[junit4] 1> Edge added 1 to innerCrossingCount
[junit4] 1> Travel outer point [X=1.0, Y=6.831927763163421E-13,
Z=-1.4926898632243605E-13]; edgeplane=2.5243548967072378E-29;
travelOutsidePlane=-1.0097419586828951E-28
[junit4] 1> Edge added 1 to outerCrossingCount
{code}
The travel outer point it incorrectly finds has a distance to each intersecting
plane that's on the order of 1e-28. That basically says it's a real
intersection given the inputs. So that second edge does intersect the outer
envelope EVEN THOUGH it doesn't look like it should, based on the endpoint.
The only other thing that can be going wrong is that the edge endpoint's bounds
are just sloppy enough to permit this intersection to be included in the
crossings list, while it really should be rejected. I'll need more diagnostics
to rule that in or out as the underlying cause, but I'm getting busy at work
now so that's not going to happen for a while.
> GeoComplexPolygon fails when intersection of travel plane with edge is near
> polygon point
> -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
> Key: LUCENE-8245
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/LUCENE-8245
> Project: Lucene - Core
> Issue Type: Bug
> Components: modules/spatial3d
> Reporter: Ignacio Vera
> Assignee: Karl Wright
> Priority: Major
> Fix For: 6.7, 7.4, master (8.0)
>
> Attachments: LUCENE-8245-case2.patch, LUCENE-8245.jpg,
> LUCENE-8245.patch
>
>
> When a travel plane crosses an edge close to an edge point , it is possible
> that the above and below planes crosses different edges. In the current
> implementation one of the crosses is missed because we only check edges that
> are crossed by the main plain and the {{within}} result is wrong.
> One possible fix is to check always the intersection of planes and edges
> regardless if they are crossed by main plane. That fixed the above issue but
> shows other issues like travel planes crossing two edges when it should be
> only one due to the fuzziness at edge intersections.
> Not sure of a fix so I add the test showing the issue.
>
>
--
This message was sent by Atlassian JIRA
(v7.6.3#76005)
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected]
For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected]
