[ 
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/KAFKA-5221?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:all-tabpanel
 ]

Abhimanyu Nagrath updated KAFKA-5221:
-------------------------------------
    Description: 
I have a single node Kafka broker and a single zookeeper (3.4.9). I am using 
new Kafka Consumer APIs. One strange thing I observed is when I am starting 
multiple Kafka consumers for multiple topics placed in a single group and on 
hitting ./kafka-consumer-groups.sh this script for the group. Few of the 
consumers are attached to the group but they do not consume any message. 
Below are the stats of group command.

        TOPIC                          PARTITION  CURRENT-OFFSET  
LOG-END-OFFSET  LAG        CONSUMER-ID                                 HOST  
    topic1 0          288             288             0          
consumer-8-c9487cd3-573b-4c97-87c1-ddf2063ab5ae   /<serverip>          
consumer-8 
    
    topic1 1          283             283             0         
consumer-8-c9487cd3-573b-4c97-87c1-ddf2063ab5ae   /<serverip>          
consumer-8 
    
    topic1 2          279             279             0         
consumer-8-c9487cd3-573b-4c97-87c1-ddf2063ab5ae   /<serverip>          
consumer-8 
    
    topic2 0          -               9               -         
consumer-1-b0476dc8-099c-4a62-a68c-e9dc9c0a5bed   /<serverip>          
consumer-1 
    
    topic2 1          -               2               -         
consumer-1-b0476dc8-099c-4a62-a68c-e9dc9c0a5bed   /<serverip>          
consumer-1 
    
    topic3 0          450             450             0         
consumer-3-63c07703-17d0-471b-8c5f-17347699f108   /<serverip>          
consumer-3 
    
    topic4                1          -               54        
        -        consumer-2-94dcc209-8377-45ce-8473-9ab0d85951c4   /<serverip>  
    
    


    topic2 2          441             441             0          
consumer-5-bcfffc99-5915-41f4-b3e4-970baa204c14   /<serverip>

So can someone help me that why for topic **topic2** partition 0 
**current-offset** is showing - and **lag** is showing - but messages are still 
there in the server as  **LOG-END-OFFSET** is showing 9.

I am having 600 GB Data distributed among 280 topics and each topic is having 
approx. 50 partitions.

This is happening very frequently and restarting the consumers solves the issue 
temporarily.

  was:
I have a single node Kafka broker and a single zookeeper (3.4.9). I am using 
new Kafka Consumer APIs. One strange thing I observed is when I am starting 
multiple Kafka consumers for multiple topics placed in a single group and on 
hitting ./kafka-consumer-groups.sh this script for the group. Few of the 
consumers are attached to the group but they do not consume any message. 
Below are the stats of group command.

        TOPIC                          PARTITION  CURRENT-OFFSET  
LOG-END-OFFSET  LAG        CONSUMER-ID                                 HOST  
    topic1 0          288             288             0          
consumer-8-c9487cd3-573b-4c97-87c1-ddf2063ab5ae   /<serverip>          
consumer-8 
    
    topic1 1          283             283             0         
consumer-8-c9487cd3-573b-4c97-87c1-ddf2063ab5ae   /<serverip>          
consumer-8 
    
    topic1 2          279             279             0         
consumer-8-c9487cd3-573b-4c97-87c1-ddf2063ab5ae   /<serverip>          
consumer-8 
    
    topic2 0          -               9               -         
consumer-1-b0476dc8-099c-4a62-a68c-e9dc9c0a5bed   /<serverip>          
consumer-1 
    
    topic2 1          -               2               -         
consumer-1-b0476dc8-099c-4a62-a68c-e9dc9c0a5bed   /<serverip>          
consumer-1 
    
    topic3 0          450             450             0         
consumer-3-63c07703-17d0-471b-8c5f-17347699f108   /<serverip>          
consumer-3 
    
    topic4                1          -               54        
        -        consumer-2-94dcc209-8377-45ce-8473-9ab0d85951c4   /<serverip>  
    
    


    topic2 2          441             441             0          
consumer-5-bcfffc99-5915-41f4-b3e4-970baa204c14   /<serverip>

So can someone help me that why for topic **topic2** partition 0 
**current-offset** is showing - and **lag** is showing - but messages are still 
there in the server as  **LOG-END-OFFSET** is showing 9.

I am having 600 GB Data distributed among 380 topics and each topic is having 
approx. 100 partitions.

This is happening very frequently and restarting the consumers solves the issue 
temporarily.


> Kafka Consumer Attached to partition but not consuming messages
> ---------------------------------------------------------------
>
>                 Key: KAFKA-5221
>                 URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/KAFKA-5221
>             Project: Kafka
>          Issue Type: Bug
>          Components: consumer
>    Affects Versions: 0.10.2.0
>         Environment: Amazon-Linux AMI 
> Hardware Specifications - (8 core, 16 GB RAM , 1 TB HardDisk)
>            Reporter: Abhimanyu Nagrath
>
> I have a single node Kafka broker and a single zookeeper (3.4.9). I am using 
> new Kafka Consumer APIs. One strange thing I observed is when I am starting 
> multiple Kafka consumers for multiple topics placed in a single group and on 
> hitting ./kafka-consumer-groups.sh this script for the group. Few of the 
> consumers are attached to the group but they do not consume any message. 
> Below are the stats of group command.
>         TOPIC                          PARTITION  CURRENT-OFFSET  
> LOG-END-OFFSET  LAG        CONSUMER-ID                                 HOST  
>     topic1 0          288             288             0          
> consumer-8-c9487cd3-573b-4c97-87c1-ddf2063ab5ae   /<serverip>          
> consumer-8 
>     
>     topic1 1          283             283             0         
> consumer-8-c9487cd3-573b-4c97-87c1-ddf2063ab5ae   /<serverip>          
> consumer-8 
>     
>     topic1 2          279             279             0         
> consumer-8-c9487cd3-573b-4c97-87c1-ddf2063ab5ae   /<serverip>          
> consumer-8 
>     
>     topic2 0          -               9               -         
> consumer-1-b0476dc8-099c-4a62-a68c-e9dc9c0a5bed   /<serverip>          
> consumer-1 
>     
>     topic2 1          -               2               -         
> consumer-1-b0476dc8-099c-4a62-a68c-e9dc9c0a5bed   /<serverip>          
> consumer-1 
>     
>     topic3 0          450             450             0         
> consumer-3-63c07703-17d0-471b-8c5f-17347699f108   /<serverip>          
> consumer-3 
>     
>     topic4                1          -               54        
>         -        consumer-2-94dcc209-8377-45ce-8473-9ab0d85951c4   
> /<serverip>      
>     
>     topic2 2          441             441             0          
> consumer-5-bcfffc99-5915-41f4-b3e4-970baa204c14   /<serverip>
> So can someone help me that why for topic **topic2** partition 0 
> **current-offset** is showing - and **lag** is showing - but messages are 
> still there in the server as  **LOG-END-OFFSET** is showing 9.
> I am having 600 GB Data distributed among 280 topics and each topic is having 
> approx. 50 partitions.
> This is happening very frequently and restarting the consumers solves the 
> issue temporarily.



--
This message was sent by Atlassian JIRA
(v6.3.15#6346)

Reply via email to